"Not failure, but low aim is sin"
About this Quote
In eight blunt words, Benjamin E. Mays flips the moral script most people inherit: the problem isn’t falling short, it’s choosing a goal so small you never have to risk falling. Calling “low aim” a sin is a deliberately charged move from an educator-theologian who understood how often society trains the marginalized to pre-shrink their ambitions. Failure can be circumstance, bad luck, even the cost of experimentation. Low aim is consent. It’s the quiet internalization of limits that were first imposed from the outside.
The line works because it refuses the comforting bargain of “at least I tried” when the trying was calibrated to avoid exposure. Mays isn’t romanticizing hustle; he’s indicting a kind of moral cowardice: the decision to protect your ego, your status, or your safety by never making a claim on the possible. That’s why “sin” lands harder than “mistake.” It frames under-aspiration as an ethical breach, not a personality quirk, because low aim has consequences: it narrows what communities imagine they deserve.
Context matters. Mays helped shape the intellectual backbone of the Civil Rights era (and mentored Martin Luther King Jr.), operating in a country structured to make “high aim” seem naive or punishable for Black students and leaders. Read there, the quote is both pep talk and political theology. It urges ambition as resistance and reframes setbacks as evidence of attempting something worthy. The real shame isn’t losing; it’s never demanding a life big enough to lose at.
The line works because it refuses the comforting bargain of “at least I tried” when the trying was calibrated to avoid exposure. Mays isn’t romanticizing hustle; he’s indicting a kind of moral cowardice: the decision to protect your ego, your status, or your safety by never making a claim on the possible. That’s why “sin” lands harder than “mistake.” It frames under-aspiration as an ethical breach, not a personality quirk, because low aim has consequences: it narrows what communities imagine they deserve.
Context matters. Mays helped shape the intellectual backbone of the Civil Rights era (and mentored Martin Luther King Jr.), operating in a country structured to make “high aim” seem naive or punishable for Black students and leaders. Read there, the quote is both pep talk and political theology. It urges ambition as resistance and reframes setbacks as evidence of attempting something worthy. The real shame isn’t losing; it’s never demanding a life big enough to lose at.
Quote Details
| Topic | Goal Setting |
|---|
More Quotes by Benjamin
Add to List










