"Nothing goes by luck in composition. It allows of no tricks. The best you can write will be the best you are"
About this Quote
Thoreau is allergic to the romantic alibi that art arrives like weather. “Nothing goes by luck” is a slap at the cult of inspiration: the comforting belief that genius is a lightning strike, not a practice. In “composition,” he insists, there are “no tricks” - no rhetorical sleight of hand that can counterfeit substance. Writing, in his view, is a moral instrument. It doesn’t just communicate who you are; it exposes who you are.
The subtext is both bracing and punitive: if your sentences feel thin, it’s not because the muse stood you up. It’s because the self behind them is underdeveloped, unexamined, or compromised. Thoreau folds craft into character. “The best you can write will be the best you are” turns the page into a mirror with harsh lighting. It’s a rebuke to the idea that style can outpace soul - that you can outsource depth to technique.
Context matters. Thoreau writes out of a 19th-century American moment obsessed with self-culture, improvement, and sincerity, and he’s a leading voice in Transcendentalism’s demand that inner life be disciplined, not merely felt. His own project in Walden is essentially compositional: revise your living as you revise a paragraph. The line lands because it refuses to flatter the writer. It offers no hack, only a standard: if you want better work, become someone capable of it.
The subtext is both bracing and punitive: if your sentences feel thin, it’s not because the muse stood you up. It’s because the self behind them is underdeveloped, unexamined, or compromised. Thoreau folds craft into character. “The best you can write will be the best you are” turns the page into a mirror with harsh lighting. It’s a rebuke to the idea that style can outpace soul - that you can outsource depth to technique.
Context matters. Thoreau writes out of a 19th-century American moment obsessed with self-culture, improvement, and sincerity, and he’s a leading voice in Transcendentalism’s demand that inner life be disciplined, not merely felt. His own project in Walden is essentially compositional: revise your living as you revise a paragraph. The line lands because it refuses to flatter the writer. It offers no hack, only a standard: if you want better work, become someone capable of it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by Henry
Add to List
