"Now there's three things you can do in a baseball game: You can win or you can lose or it can rain"
About this Quote
Stengel’s line lands because it punctures the macho mythology of sports with a shrug of meteorology. Baseball sells itself as a morality play - effort, grit, destiny - but he re-centers the game on a stubborn fact every fan knows and every announcer tries to talk around: the world doesn’t care about your narrative. You can do everything “right,” and the sky can still call the whole thing off.
The genius is in the fake simplicity. “Three things” sets you up for tidy certainty, then the third option detonates the frame. Winning and losing imply control, agency, accountability. Rain is neither opponent nor mistake; it’s pure contingency. Stengel isn’t just being funny (though it’s a perfectly timed vaudeville beat). He’s giving a managerial worldview: outcomes aren’t clean, and leadership often means absorbing randomness without turning it into an alibi.
Context matters. Stengel coached through baseball’s grind-it-out eras, when travel was rougher, fields were worse, and postponements were common. The joke is also a manager’s gallows humor: you plan, you strategize, you motivate, then you stare at the tarp. That’s baseball’s daily lesson in humility, packaged as a one-liner.
Subtextually, it’s a defense mechanism and a philosophy. It tells players not to over-romanticize either victory or defeat, because even the scoreboard competes with forces outside the stadium. In an industry built on hot takes and blame, Stengel offers an anti-heroic truth: sometimes the story isn’t yours to finish.
The genius is in the fake simplicity. “Three things” sets you up for tidy certainty, then the third option detonates the frame. Winning and losing imply control, agency, accountability. Rain is neither opponent nor mistake; it’s pure contingency. Stengel isn’t just being funny (though it’s a perfectly timed vaudeville beat). He’s giving a managerial worldview: outcomes aren’t clean, and leadership often means absorbing randomness without turning it into an alibi.
Context matters. Stengel coached through baseball’s grind-it-out eras, when travel was rougher, fields were worse, and postponements were common. The joke is also a manager’s gallows humor: you plan, you strategize, you motivate, then you stare at the tarp. That’s baseball’s daily lesson in humility, packaged as a one-liner.
Subtextually, it’s a defense mechanism and a philosophy. It tells players not to over-romanticize either victory or defeat, because even the scoreboard competes with forces outside the stadium. In an industry built on hot takes and blame, Stengel offers an anti-heroic truth: sometimes the story isn’t yours to finish.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|---|
| Source | Wikiquote — Casey Stengel: contains the quote "There are three things you can do in baseball: win, lose, or get rained out." (commonly attributed to Casey Stengel). |
More Quotes by Casey
Add to List

