"Our government has kept us in a perpetual state of fear - kept us in a continuous stampede of patriotic fervor - with the cry of grave national emergency"
About this Quote
MacArthur’s line is a general’s accusation aimed not at an enemy abroad but at the domestic machinery of consent. The choice of “perpetual” and “continuous” makes fear sound less like an episodic response to danger than a policy instrument, routinized until it becomes the atmosphere citizens breathe. Then comes the killer metaphor: a “stampede.” That word strips “patriotic fervor” of dignity, recasting it as herd panic, movement without thought, velocity without direction. It’s contempt disguised as warning.
The intent is double-edged. On the surface, he’s indicting leaders who justify extraordinary power with the “cry of grave national emergency.” Underneath, he’s challenging the idea that loyalty equals obedience. MacArthur frames patriotism as something that can be engineered, whipped up, deployed like ammunition against dissent. “Cry” is doing work here: emergencies aren’t merely declared; they’re performed, repeated, amplified until they harden into common sense.
Context matters because MacArthur was no peacenik outsider; he was one of the most decorated American soldiers of his era, a man whose career was built on national mobilization. That gives the critique bite: it’s coming from inside the national-security priesthood. Read against the mid-century backdrop - global war, the early Cold War’s permanent readiness, the rise of the “national security state” - the quote anticipates a modern rhythm of politics where fear is not an exception but a renewable resource. The subtext is bleakly pragmatic: if emergency is perpetual, հրապարակ is always pliable, and democracy becomes management by alarm.
The intent is double-edged. On the surface, he’s indicting leaders who justify extraordinary power with the “cry of grave national emergency.” Underneath, he’s challenging the idea that loyalty equals obedience. MacArthur frames patriotism as something that can be engineered, whipped up, deployed like ammunition against dissent. “Cry” is doing work here: emergencies aren’t merely declared; they’re performed, repeated, amplified until they harden into common sense.
Context matters because MacArthur was no peacenik outsider; he was one of the most decorated American soldiers of his era, a man whose career was built on national mobilization. That gives the critique bite: it’s coming from inside the national-security priesthood. Read against the mid-century backdrop - global war, the early Cold War’s permanent readiness, the rise of the “national security state” - the quote anticipates a modern rhythm of politics where fear is not an exception but a renewable resource. The subtext is bleakly pragmatic: if emergency is perpetual, հրապարակ is always pliable, and democracy becomes management by alarm.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|---|
| Source | Douglas MacArthur, "Farewell Address to Congress", April 19, 1951 , contains the line "Our government has kept us in a perpetual state of fear - kept us in a continuous stampede of patriotic fervor - with the cry of grave national emergency." |
More Quotes by Douglas
Add to List




