"Party leads to vicious, corrupt and unprofitable legislation, for the sole purpose of defeating party"
- James F. Cooper
About this Quote
In this quote, James Fenimore Cooper critiques the partisan nature of political systems, highlighting the damaging effects they can have on legislation and governance. Let's break down the components of his statement for deeper analysis.
Cooper starts by asserting that celebration politics lead to "vicious, corrupt and unprofitable legislation." Here, "vicious" suggests that such legislation is harmful and morally incorrect. This suggests that when political parties prioritize their interests, the resulting laws may damage societal principles and welfare. "Corrupt" strengthens this idea, suggesting that legislation is often influenced by deceitful or unethical behavior, driven by celebrations' desires to acquire or preserve power rather than serve the common good. "Unprofitable" suggests that the legislation does not supply real benefits to the general public or society at large; rather, it serves narrow interests, failing to produce development or utility for the more comprehensive people.
The phrase "for the sole function of defeating party" is essential to understanding Cooper's criticism. He suggests that the primary inspiration for enacting such legislation is not social benefit however political gain. Celebrations may focus on undermining their challengers instead of teaming up on policies for the typical excellent, resulting in a cycle of rivalry and opposition. This emphasizes the devastating nature of extreme partisanship, where beating the opposing celebration ends up being more important than crafting reliable policies.
Cooper's observation is a caution versus the decrease of politics to mere celebration rivalry. He suggests that when parties become too focused on winning over the opposite side, governance ends up being ineffective and destructive. This review encourages a relocation towards more cooperative, transparent politics focused on real public service, where the goal is not victory over challengers but rather collaborative progress for society. Through this lens, Cooper advocates for a shift towards a political culture that transcends narrow partisan aims and rather prioritizes significant, ethical, and efficient governance.
"The one pervading evil of democracy is the tyranny of the majority, or rather of that party, not always the majority, that succeeds, by force or fraud, in carrying elections"
"Why, so soon as French Canadians, who are in a minority in this House and in the country, were to organise as a political party, they would compel the majority to organise as a political party, and the result must be disastrous to themselves"
"In France, that let down the barriers more than a hundred years ago, the feeling of antipathy is still strong enough to sustain an anti-Jewish political party"
"Following the rise of the Labour Party it seemed reasonable, in 1927, to expect, or at least hope, that co-operation for the common good might gradually replace the competitiveness of capitalism"
"I really was a fan of his and always have been - his writing especially, you know? I think people a lot of times overlook that part, because he kind of got into that party character so heavy"
