"Pugnacity is a form of courage, but a very bad form"
- Sinclair Lewis
About this Quote
In the quote "Pugnacity is a kind of courage, however a very bad kind" by Sinclair Lewis, there's a nuanced review of the nature of nerve and the function that hostility or combativeness plays within it. To unpack this, we need to consider both the undertones of "pugnacity" and the wider context of "guts.".
Pugnacity describes a natural disposition towards aggression, fight, or a desire to combat and argue. It includes an instinctive readiness to confront obstacles head-on however typically with an impulse-driven, confrontational approach. Such habits is frequently seen in individuals who respond rapidly with little forethought and tend towards conflict as a method of solving problems.
On the other hand, nerve is traditionally viewed as a noble quality, defined by the self-control, bravery, and the ability to deal with worries, difficulty, or hardship with determination and resolve. True guts typically includes determined factor to consider, compassion, and the smart discernment of when to persevere and when to seek option, serene resolutions.
By recommending that pugnacity is a type of guts, Lewis acknowledges that there is a courageous component in the determination to face fight and not avoid difficulty or hardship. After all, it takes a specific boldness to engage straight with opposition or hazard. However, by identifying it "an extremely bad form", he highlights the recklessness and lack of elegance that characterizes pugnacity. Such courage, driven mainly by spontaneous hostility and not balanced by knowledge or empathy, can result in unnecessary conflict and damage. It lacks the depth and foresight typically needed to solve complex concerns effectively and constructively.
Lewis's quote, for that reason, functions as a critique of aggressive habits that masquerades as bravery. Through this lens, true nerve must be strategic and attentively applied instead of blindly and thoughtlessly confrontational. It requires a reevaluation of our understanding of nerve, prompting us to value the value of rationality and compassion along with bravery.
About the Author