"Reasoning at every step he treads, Man yet mistakes his way, Whilst meaner things, whom instinct leads, Are rarely known to stray"
About this Quote
Cowper skewers the Enlightenment-era confidence that humans, armed with reason, naturally progress toward truth. The couplet moves like a neat moral syllogism and then undercuts it: "Reasoning at every step" sounds like a compliment until the next line turns it into an indictment. The verb "treads" matters. Reason isn’t flight or vision here; it’s plodding, self-important footwork. And still, we "mistake" our way - not from ignorance, but in spite of constant calculation. Cowper’s sting is that rationality, treated as a self-sufficient compass, becomes a kind of vanity.
The real bite comes from the phrase "meaner things". It’s an old hierarchical word - animals and simpler creatures, lower on the Great Chain of Being. Cowper lets that hierarchy stand just long enough to flip it. The supposedly inferior are "rarely known to stray" because instinct gives them a directness the human mind can’t stop complicating. The subtext isn’t that instinct is noble and reason is trash; it’s that humans are uniquely talented at rationalizing error. We don’t just get lost. We build persuasive arguments for staying lost.
Contextually, Cowper writes from a late-18th-century Britain dazzled by science and system-building, yet also crowded with moral contradiction: empire, slavery debates, class misery, private despair. The line reads like a theological caution as much as a psychological one: reason is a tool, not a savior. Without humility - without some tether beyond the self - the most "reasonable" person can become the most confidently wrong.
The real bite comes from the phrase "meaner things". It’s an old hierarchical word - animals and simpler creatures, lower on the Great Chain of Being. Cowper lets that hierarchy stand just long enough to flip it. The supposedly inferior are "rarely known to stray" because instinct gives them a directness the human mind can’t stop complicating. The subtext isn’t that instinct is noble and reason is trash; it’s that humans are uniquely talented at rationalizing error. We don’t just get lost. We build persuasive arguments for staying lost.
Contextually, Cowper writes from a late-18th-century Britain dazzled by science and system-building, yet also crowded with moral contradiction: empire, slavery debates, class misery, private despair. The line reads like a theological caution as much as a psychological one: reason is a tool, not a savior. Without humility - without some tether beyond the self - the most "reasonable" person can become the most confidently wrong.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|
More Quotes by William
Add to List
