"Right is right, even if everyone is against it, and wrong is wrong, even if everyone is for it"
About this Quote
Penn’s line lands like a moral gavel: legitimacy doesn’t come from applause. In an era when “truth” was regularly decided by crown, church, and mob pressure, he strips righteousness down to something stubbornly non-democratic. The rhetoric is deliberately blunt - a pair of mirrored clauses that turn social consensus into a flimsy metric. The symmetry does the persuading: “everyone” appears on both sides, shrinking the crowd from moral judge to unreliable weather.
The intent is political as much as spiritual. Penn, a Quaker leader repeatedly jailed for dissent, is speaking from the lived reality that majorities can be instruments of persecution, not progress. Quakerism’s emphasis on the “inner light” makes this more than a stoic slogan; it’s an argument for conscience as a higher authority than institutions. The subtext is a warning about fashionable cruelty: when “everyone is for it,” wrong gains the camouflage of normalcy, and normalcy is what makes injustice efficient.
The quote also pre-emptively rebukes cowardice. It doesn’t flatter the listener as a lone hero; it dares them to accept the social cost of being right. At the same time, it rejects the romantic mistake that being unpopular automatically makes you virtuous. Penn isn’t praising contrarianism. He’s drawing a hard line between moral reality and social reality - and insisting that the former doesn’t bend just because the latter votes.
The intent is political as much as spiritual. Penn, a Quaker leader repeatedly jailed for dissent, is speaking from the lived reality that majorities can be instruments of persecution, not progress. Quakerism’s emphasis on the “inner light” makes this more than a stoic slogan; it’s an argument for conscience as a higher authority than institutions. The subtext is a warning about fashionable cruelty: when “everyone is for it,” wrong gains the camouflage of normalcy, and normalcy is what makes injustice efficient.
The quote also pre-emptively rebukes cowardice. It doesn’t flatter the listener as a lone hero; it dares them to accept the social cost of being right. At the same time, it rejects the romantic mistake that being unpopular automatically makes you virtuous. Penn isn’t praising contrarianism. He’s drawing a hard line between moral reality and social reality - and insisting that the former doesn’t bend just because the latter votes.
Quote Details
| Topic | Honesty & Integrity |
|---|---|
| Source | Later attribution: Maybe God Is Right After All (Cynthia Heald, 2016) modern compilationISBN: 9781496417626 · ID: sTNYCwAAQBAJ
Evidence: ... William Penn was right: “Right is right, even if everyone is against it; and wrong is wrong, even if everyone is for it.” I was beginning to wholeheartedly agree with Penn, especially that right is right even if everyone is against ... Other candidates (1) William Penn (William Penn) compilation36.3% orgives first wins the lawrel if i am even with my enemy the debt is paid but if i forgive it i oblige him for ev |
More Quotes by William
Add to List




