"Since we have to speak well of the dead, let's knock them while they're alive"

John French Sloan's quote, "Since we need to speak well of the dead, let's knock them while they're alive", offers a thought-provoking commentary on social standards regarding how we perceive and speak about others. This declaration can be unloaded on numerous levels.

At first glance, the quote appears to review the customary practice of admiring individuals posthumously, no matter their genuine character or actions throughout their life time. It points to the propensity to neglect or forgive the flaws of the departed, choosing rather to keep in mind them in a positive light. The concept that "we have to speak well of the dead" suggests an obligatory social rules, rooted maybe in the respect generally accorded to the deceased or in a sense of diplomacy meant to console the living.

However, the juxtaposition with the expression "let's knock them while they're alive" introduces a paradoxical twist. It suggests that while individuals may avoid slamming the dead, they do not hesitate to critique or disparage the living. This irony highlights a societal contradiction or hypocrisy-- judging people roughly during their life times, while engaging in sanitization or glorification once they have passed. It appears to motivate a more balanced and sincere appraisal of individuals while they are still around to benefit from or respond to such critiques. By suggesting we attend to faults while individuals are alive, Sloan may be promoting for a culture where constructive criticism can lead to real development and redemption.

In another light, Sloan's quote could be seen as an encouragement to resolve conflicts, express gratitude, or perhaps slam constructively while individuals live, rather than postponing such thoughts or regrets until it's too late. The declaration provokes reflection on our social characteristics-- whether we choose openness or camouflage our true sensations until it's too late for them to have any significant impact. In general, this quote acts as a timely to examine our approach to interaction, legacy, and the real essence of honoring a person's life.