"Surprising as it may seem, this study indicates that similar conditions are best for all sorts of races"
About this Quote
“Surprising as it may seem” is doing the heavy lifting here, a little stage whisper from an educator trying to pre-empt the audience’s instincts. Huntington isn’t just reporting data; he’s managing expectations in a period when “race” was treated as a scientific category and climate theories were routinely marshaled to rank human groups. The line’s apparent generosity - “best for all sorts of races” - lands as a corrective to the era’s cruder claims that different “races” were naturally suited to different environments. He’s positioning his work as empirical, even mildly heretical, within a field drenched in assumptions.
But the subtext is not as egalitarian as it sounds. The key word is “best,” which smuggles in a normative standard: best for what, and measured by whose outcomes? In Huntington’s world, “best” often meant productivity, energy, and the kind of economic output prized by industrial modernity. By casting environmental “conditions” as destiny’s thermostat, the sentence keeps the causal engine outside politics: inequality becomes a matter of climate optimization rather than colonial extraction, labor exploitation, or segregated institutions.
Context matters: Huntington was a leading voice in environmental determinism, a framework that could seem progressive by arguing for common human capacities, yet still functioned as a refined tool for social sorting. The quote works because it offers a soothing universal - one set of “ideal” conditions - while preserving the era’s obsession with measuring, comparing, and disciplining populations under the banner of neutral science.
But the subtext is not as egalitarian as it sounds. The key word is “best,” which smuggles in a normative standard: best for what, and measured by whose outcomes? In Huntington’s world, “best” often meant productivity, energy, and the kind of economic output prized by industrial modernity. By casting environmental “conditions” as destiny’s thermostat, the sentence keeps the causal engine outside politics: inequality becomes a matter of climate optimization rather than colonial extraction, labor exploitation, or segregated institutions.
Context matters: Huntington was a leading voice in environmental determinism, a framework that could seem progressive by arguing for common human capacities, yet still functioned as a refined tool for social sorting. The quote works because it offers a soothing universal - one set of “ideal” conditions - while preserving the era’s obsession with measuring, comparing, and disciplining populations under the banner of neutral science.
Quote Details
| Topic | Equality |
|---|
More Quotes by Ellsworth
Add to List




