"Tell us your phobias and we will tell you what you are afraid of"
About this Quote
Benchley’s line works like a mock clinical intake form that immediately flips into a con. You come in expecting precision - phobias, the Greek-sounding labels, the reassuring idea that your panic has a name - and he offers a punchline diagnosis so obvious it’s insulting. That’s the trick: it exposes how often “expert” language is just a fancier way of repeating what you already know.
The intent is satirical, aimed at the early-20th-century boom in self-help, pop psychology, and the prestige of classification. A phobia sounds scientific; it suggests depth, etiology, maybe even a cure. Benchley punctures that promise by implying the whole apparatus can collapse into tautology. Tell us you have arachnophobia and, congratulations, we’ve discovered you fear spiders. The joke isn’t only that the answer is redundant; it’s that we crave redundancy when it comes wrapped in authority.
Subtext: naming can be a comfort blanket and a dodge. Labels let us outsource interpretation - to doctors, to jargon, to systems that turn messy anxieties into tidy categories. Benchley isn’t denying fear; he’s skeptical of the cultural machinery that turns fear into an identity badge or an intellectual parlor game.
Context matters. Benchley, a New Yorker-era comedian with a dry, educated persona, thrived on skewering modern life’s bureaucratic seriousness. His humor treats expertise as theater: impressive costumes, predictable lines, and an audience eager to believe the performance means something. The quote lands because it’s both a one-liner and a warning: if your explanation doesn’t add insight, it’s not understanding - it’s decoration.
The intent is satirical, aimed at the early-20th-century boom in self-help, pop psychology, and the prestige of classification. A phobia sounds scientific; it suggests depth, etiology, maybe even a cure. Benchley punctures that promise by implying the whole apparatus can collapse into tautology. Tell us you have arachnophobia and, congratulations, we’ve discovered you fear spiders. The joke isn’t only that the answer is redundant; it’s that we crave redundancy when it comes wrapped in authority.
Subtext: naming can be a comfort blanket and a dodge. Labels let us outsource interpretation - to doctors, to jargon, to systems that turn messy anxieties into tidy categories. Benchley isn’t denying fear; he’s skeptical of the cultural machinery that turns fear into an identity badge or an intellectual parlor game.
Context matters. Benchley, a New Yorker-era comedian with a dry, educated persona, thrived on skewering modern life’s bureaucratic seriousness. His humor treats expertise as theater: impressive costumes, predictable lines, and an audience eager to believe the performance means something. The quote lands because it’s both a one-liner and a warning: if your explanation doesn’t add insight, it’s not understanding - it’s decoration.
Quote Details
| Topic | Fear |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List




