"That which has been believed by everyone, always and everywhere, has every chance of being false"
About this Quote
Valery’s line is a lit match held under the thick curtain of “common sense.” He doesn’t just distrust consensus; he treats unanimity as a warning label. The paradox is the point: if something has been believed by everyone, always and everywhere, it likely survived not because it’s true, but because it’s useful. A belief that travels intact across centuries and cultures usually does so by being simple, flattering, and socially adhesive - the kind of idea that makes the world feel legible, not the kind that withstands scrutiny.
As a poet steeped in the modernist break with inherited certainties, Valery is pushing back against tradition as an intellectual reflex. The subtext is a critique of how cultures launder assumptions into “natural law.” Universality becomes less evidence than alibi: a way to stop thinking. That’s why “every chance” lands so sharply. He’s not offering a new dogma (“the opposite is true”), but a method: treat the oldest, widest agreement as the most likely to be ideology.
The context matters. Valery wrote in an era when “everyone knows” had sponsored catastrophes - nationalist myths, racial pseudo-science, the pomp of empire. Modernity exposed how quickly a civilization can confuse shared belief with shared reality. His skepticism is not nihilism; it’s hygiene. Truth, in Valery’s world, is rarely democratic. It’s earned, revised, and often unpopular.
As a poet steeped in the modernist break with inherited certainties, Valery is pushing back against tradition as an intellectual reflex. The subtext is a critique of how cultures launder assumptions into “natural law.” Universality becomes less evidence than alibi: a way to stop thinking. That’s why “every chance” lands so sharply. He’s not offering a new dogma (“the opposite is true”), but a method: treat the oldest, widest agreement as the most likely to be ideology.
The context matters. Valery wrote in an era when “everyone knows” had sponsored catastrophes - nationalist myths, racial pseudo-science, the pomp of empire. Modernity exposed how quickly a civilization can confuse shared belief with shared reality. His skepticism is not nihilism; it’s hygiene. Truth, in Valery’s world, is rarely democratic. It’s earned, revised, and often unpopular.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|
More Quotes by Paul
Add to List










