"The automobile, both a cause and an effect of this decentralization, is ideally suited for our vast landscape and our generally confused and contrary commuting patterns"
About this Quote
Yates smuggles a whole critique of American life into a sentence that sounds like infrastructure trivia. The automobile isn’t just a tool for getting from A to B; it’s a feedback loop. Calling it “both a cause and an effect” turns the car into a kind of national habit-forming device: we spread out because we drive, and we drive because we’ve spread out. That circularity is the point. It quietly indicts the way policy, real estate, and everyday convenience colluded to make distance feel normal.
The phrase “ideally suited for our vast landscape” borrows the language of destiny. It nods to the popular myth that the U.S. was always meant to be a car country because it’s big, as if geography alone mandated asphalt. Yates’s edge is that he pairs that flattering claim with a jab: “generally confused and contrary commuting patterns.” That’s not a technical description; it’s a cultural diagnosis. The American commute is “contrary” because it often defies any clean logic of city center and suburb, of work and home, of efficiency and sanity. It’s a daily enactment of decentralized living: jobs in one direction, schools in another, errands everywhere, all stitched together by personal vehicles.
As an editor steeped in car culture and its contradictions, Yates writes with a wry pragmatism. He acknowledges the car’s genuine fit for American scale while hinting that the “fit” was engineered and then rationalized. The sentence reads like a shrug that doubles as an accusation.
The phrase “ideally suited for our vast landscape” borrows the language of destiny. It nods to the popular myth that the U.S. was always meant to be a car country because it’s big, as if geography alone mandated asphalt. Yates’s edge is that he pairs that flattering claim with a jab: “generally confused and contrary commuting patterns.” That’s not a technical description; it’s a cultural diagnosis. The American commute is “contrary” because it often defies any clean logic of city center and suburb, of work and home, of efficiency and sanity. It’s a daily enactment of decentralized living: jobs in one direction, schools in another, errands everywhere, all stitched together by personal vehicles.
As an editor steeped in car culture and its contradictions, Yates writes with a wry pragmatism. He acknowledges the car’s genuine fit for American scale while hinting that the “fit” was engineered and then rationalized. The sentence reads like a shrug that doubles as an accusation.
Quote Details
| Topic | Road Trip |
|---|
More Quotes by Brock
Add to List
