"The environmental crisis arises from a fundamental fault: our systems of production - in industry, agriculture, energy and transportation - essential as they are, make people sick and die"
About this Quote
Commoner’s line refuses the comforting fiction that the environmental crisis is a matter of litter, personal virtue, or a few “bad actors.” He pins it on design: the baseline operating logic of modern production. That’s why the quote hits with the bluntness of a lab result. “Fundamental fault” is diagnostic language, not moral scolding. The implication is structural: if the system is built to externalize harm, then efficiency and growth aren’t neutral achievements, they’re delivery mechanisms.
The rhetorical move is also slyly political. Commoner lists “industry, agriculture, energy and transportation” like a prosecutor reading charges, then undercuts any technocratic defense with “essential as they are.” He anticipates the rebuttal - we can’t live without these systems - and flips it into the indictment. The subtext: necessity doesn’t absolve you; it raises the standard. If what we can’t do without is also what is poisoning us, then the crisis isn’t a side effect. It’s a core feature being treated as a rounding error.
Context matters. Commoner emerged as a public scientist in the mid-20th century, when environmentalism was being pulled between consumer-focused “do your part” messaging and sharper critiques of corporate power, chemical agriculture, fossil fuels, and regulatory capture. He’s firmly in the latter camp, arguing that pollution isn’t an accident; it’s the predictable output of choices made in boardrooms and policy rooms.
The line’s grim force comes from collapsing “environment” into “health.” It’s not about saving scenic vistas. It’s about a production model that, while feeding and moving us, also quietly writes obituaries.
The rhetorical move is also slyly political. Commoner lists “industry, agriculture, energy and transportation” like a prosecutor reading charges, then undercuts any technocratic defense with “essential as they are.” He anticipates the rebuttal - we can’t live without these systems - and flips it into the indictment. The subtext: necessity doesn’t absolve you; it raises the standard. If what we can’t do without is also what is poisoning us, then the crisis isn’t a side effect. It’s a core feature being treated as a rounding error.
Context matters. Commoner emerged as a public scientist in the mid-20th century, when environmentalism was being pulled between consumer-focused “do your part” messaging and sharper critiques of corporate power, chemical agriculture, fossil fuels, and regulatory capture. He’s firmly in the latter camp, arguing that pollution isn’t an accident; it’s the predictable output of choices made in boardrooms and policy rooms.
The line’s grim force comes from collapsing “environment” into “health.” It’s not about saving scenic vistas. It’s about a production model that, while feeding and moving us, also quietly writes obituaries.
Quote Details
| Topic | Health |
|---|---|
| Source | Barry Commoner, The Closing Circle: Nature, Man, and Technology (1971) — passage attributed to Commoner: “The environmental crisis arises from a fundamental fault: our systems of production ... make people sick and die.” |
More Quotes by Barry
Add to List
