"The great are only great because we are on our knees. Let us rise!"
About this Quote
Greatness, Proudhon snarls, is rarely a natural fact. It is a posture we adopt. “The great are only great because we are on our knees” flips prestige into a kind of choreography: elites don’t merely stand taller; they are elevated by the public’s practiced crouch. The line is engineered to sting because it makes hierarchy feel physical and a little humiliating, turning deference into an action we can stop performing.
Proudhon’s intent is less to curse individual “great men” than to indict the social machinery that manufactures them. The subtext is proto-sociological and relentlessly political: power is relational. If authority depends on obedience, then obedience is not a moral obligation but a renewable resource. The most radical move in the quote is that it relocates responsibility. It’s not only rulers who must be confronted; it’s the habits of submission - the cultural training that teaches people to confuse order with justice and status with merit.
“Let us rise!” is a deliberately simple imperative, and its simplicity is the point. Proudhon wrote in a 19th-century France roiled by revolutions, restorations, and industrial upheaval, where “economist” could mean a combatant in the war over property, labor, and legitimacy. The sentence reads like an anti-monarchist slogan, but it fits his broader anarchist critique: domination survives because it is normalized, repeated, and internalized.
The rhetoric works because it offers a clean exit ramp. No policy, no committee, no savior - just the refusal to kneel. It’s empowerment with a knife edge: liberation begins as a change in posture, then spreads.
Proudhon’s intent is less to curse individual “great men” than to indict the social machinery that manufactures them. The subtext is proto-sociological and relentlessly political: power is relational. If authority depends on obedience, then obedience is not a moral obligation but a renewable resource. The most radical move in the quote is that it relocates responsibility. It’s not only rulers who must be confronted; it’s the habits of submission - the cultural training that teaches people to confuse order with justice and status with merit.
“Let us rise!” is a deliberately simple imperative, and its simplicity is the point. Proudhon wrote in a 19th-century France roiled by revolutions, restorations, and industrial upheaval, where “economist” could mean a combatant in the war over property, labor, and legitimacy. The sentence reads like an anti-monarchist slogan, but it fits his broader anarchist critique: domination survives because it is normalized, repeated, and internalized.
The rhetoric works because it offers a clean exit ramp. No policy, no committee, no savior - just the refusal to kneel. It’s empowerment with a knife edge: liberation begins as a change in posture, then spreads.
Quote Details
| Topic | Equality |
|---|---|
| Source | Later attribution: Quote Junkie (Hagopian Institute, 2008) modern compilationISBN: 9781438248561 · ID: xj-JmykO2ZEC
Evidence: ... Pierre-Joseph Proudhon The great are only great because we are on our knees. Let us rise! Pierre-Joseph Proudhon When deeds speak, words are nothing. Pierre-Joseph Proudhon Art includes everything that stimulates the desire to live ... Other candidates (1) Pierre-Joseph Proudhon (Pierre-Joseph Proudhon) compilation40.0% ion has come the face of the earth will be renewed under a new son let the prese |
More Quotes by Pierre-Joseph
Add to List









