"The key fact missed most often by social scientists utilizing documentary films for data, is this: documentary films are not found or reported things; they're made things"
About this Quote
Bruce Jackson's quote highlights a nuanced understanding of documentary that is often neglected, especially by social researchers who utilize these films as data sources. At its core, the quote distinguishes between the nature of documentary and other types of data usually used in social science research study.
Jackson suggests that a common misconception is the treatment of documentary films as raw, unmediated transmissions of truth-- a simple, discovered object representing accurate truth. However, he asserts that documentary films are, instead, "made things". This indicates that they are built artifacts, not unlike any other cultural production. The process behind these films involves selective recording, editing, and narrative structuring, all of which present layers of intention and interpretation imposed by the filmmakers.
Documentaries, for that reason, are formed by the perspectives, options, and sometimes predispositions of their creators. These choices affect what is illustrated, how it is portrayed, and what is neglected. This constructed nature challenges the idea of documentaries as pure, objective information. They are more comparable to interpretations of truth than to direct windows into it. This suggests that when social scientists engage with documentaries, they are engaging with a constructed version of truth that should be evaluated seriously, just like any secondary source.
Jackson's insight encourages researchers to consider the filmmaker's voice and the movie's context as considerable elements influencing the film's content and discussion. In acknowledging that documentaries are "made things", researchers can establish a more important approach, questioning the story, considering the filmmaker's potential agendas, and understanding the socio-cultural context that shaped the movie.
Eventually, Jackson's observation underscores the significance of crucial engagement with documentaries. It works as a pointer that while documentaries can be important sources of insight into social phenomena, they must be comprehended as complex constructs rather than simple factual accounts. This recognition permits a richer, more nuanced interpretation of films as part of social science research study.
About the Author