"The Odyssey is, indeed, one of the greatest of all stories, it is the original romance of the West; but the Iliad, though a magnificent poem, is not much of a story"

In this quote, literary critic George Saintsbury is comparing two legendary poems credited to the ancient Greek poet Homer: "The Odyssey" and "The Iliad". Saintsbury expresses a strong gratitude for "The Odyssey", describing it as "among the greatest of all stories" and calling it "the initial romance of the West". This characterization highlights the poem's value not only in the canon of Western literature however likewise in setting the groundwork for storytelling traditions in the West. "The Odyssey" is well-known for its fascinating narrative, abundant with experience, mythological encounters, and the enduring theme of a hero's journey home. Its explorations of complex characters, such as the creative Odysseus and the faithful Penelope, together with universal themes of perseverance, commitment, and the look for identity, contribute to its long lasting legacy as a fundamental romantic tale.

Conversely, Saintsbury's talk about "The Iliad" recommend a different perspective on its narrative quality. While he acknowledges it as "a splendid poem", indicating acknowledgment of its literary and poetic quality, he keeps in mind that it is "very little of a story". This critique may stem from "The Iliad's" focus on a more narrow set of events-- the wrath of Achilles during the Trojan War-- and its less varied narrative structure, focusing primarily on styles of honor, rage, and the brutality of war. The poem's portrayal of its hero, Achilles, and the tragic nature of its storyline center around extreme emotions and plain truths of human conflict, which may contrast with the adventurous and episodic nature of "The Odyssey."

In essence, Saintsbury is applauding "The Odyssey" for its narrative appeal and romantic adventure, positioning it as an influential impact in storytelling. At the very same time, he reveres "The Iliad" for its poetic splendour, while offering a nuanced review of its more minimal storytelling appeal.