"The only secrets are the secrets that keep themselves"
About this Quote
Shaw’s line doesn’t just puncture the romance of secrecy; it shrugs at it like a practiced skeptic. “The only secrets are the secrets that keep themselves” is a neat reversal that treats human discretion as basically fictional. People don’t guard truths so much as perform the idea of guarding them, and Shaw, ever the dramatist of social hypocrisy, suggests that most “secrets” survive only when they’re protected by structure, not virtue.
The intent is quietly ruthless: to move secrecy out of the moral realm and into the mechanical one. If a secret depends on someone’s willpower, it’s already on borrowed time. The secrets that endure are the ones with no audience, no paper trail, no loose-lipped confidant, no institutional incentive to leak. In other words, they keep themselves because conditions keep them, not because people do.
The subtext is classic Shaw: a distrust of sanctimony and a fascination with how societies launder self-interest into respectability. People swear loyalty, pledge silence, make solemn promises, then crack under vanity, guilt, or the simple urge to narrate their own lives. Shaw’s theater is full of characters who weaponize “confidences” and “reputations,” turning private knowledge into social currency. This aphorism treats that exchange rate as inevitable.
Context matters: Shaw wrote in an age of drawing-room politics, rigid class codes, and public moral posturing - a world where what you knew, and whom you could embarrass, often mattered more than what was true. The line lands because it’s funny in its bleakness: a maxim that sounds like wisdom, but functions as an accusation.
The intent is quietly ruthless: to move secrecy out of the moral realm and into the mechanical one. If a secret depends on someone’s willpower, it’s already on borrowed time. The secrets that endure are the ones with no audience, no paper trail, no loose-lipped confidant, no institutional incentive to leak. In other words, they keep themselves because conditions keep them, not because people do.
The subtext is classic Shaw: a distrust of sanctimony and a fascination with how societies launder self-interest into respectability. People swear loyalty, pledge silence, make solemn promises, then crack under vanity, guilt, or the simple urge to narrate their own lives. Shaw’s theater is full of characters who weaponize “confidences” and “reputations,” turning private knowledge into social currency. This aphorism treats that exchange rate as inevitable.
Context matters: Shaw wrote in an age of drawing-room politics, rigid class codes, and public moral posturing - a world where what you knew, and whom you could embarrass, often mattered more than what was true. The line lands because it’s funny in its bleakness: a maxim that sounds like wisdom, but functions as an accusation.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|
More Quotes by George
Add to List









