"The problem with cats is that they get the exact same look on their face whether they see a moth or an axe-murderer"
About this Quote
Cats, Poundstone suggests, are the ultimate unreliable narrators: all signal, no legible meaning. The joke lands because it takes a familiar household mystery - the cat freezing, pupils blown, body coiled - and spikes it with a wildly disproportionate threat. A moth and an axe-murderer should not share a facial expression. Yet anyone who has lived with a cat knows they do, and that recognition is the laugh.
The specific intent is to puncture the cozy fantasy that pets are emotional sidekicks who will confirm reality for us. Dogs perform reassurance on demand. Cats perform intensity, and they refuse to clarify what the intensity is for. Poundstone’s punchline plays on our need for interpretability: we want the animal to tell us whether to be charmed or afraid, and the cat, in its blank little mask, declines.
Subtext: human beings are desperate to read the world through faces. We treat expression as a kind of user interface for danger, desire, and intention. Cats short-circuit that system, and the result is both comedy and low-grade anxiety. The axe-murderer is not just absurd escalation; it’s the intrusion of modern paranoia into domestic space, the way threat narratives ride shotgun with everyday life.
Context matters: Poundstone’s observational style thrives on deflating sentimentality with crisp exaggeration. Here, she turns pet ownership into a commentary on control. We invite animals into our homes, then discover they won’t help us feel in charge of anything - not even our own fear.
The specific intent is to puncture the cozy fantasy that pets are emotional sidekicks who will confirm reality for us. Dogs perform reassurance on demand. Cats perform intensity, and they refuse to clarify what the intensity is for. Poundstone’s punchline plays on our need for interpretability: we want the animal to tell us whether to be charmed or afraid, and the cat, in its blank little mask, declines.
Subtext: human beings are desperate to read the world through faces. We treat expression as a kind of user interface for danger, desire, and intention. Cats short-circuit that system, and the result is both comedy and low-grade anxiety. The axe-murderer is not just absurd escalation; it’s the intrusion of modern paranoia into domestic space, the way threat narratives ride shotgun with everyday life.
Context matters: Poundstone’s observational style thrives on deflating sentimentality with crisp exaggeration. Here, she turns pet ownership into a commentary on control. We invite animals into our homes, then discover they won’t help us feel in charge of anything - not even our own fear.
Quote Details
| Topic | Cat |
|---|---|
| Source | Attributed to Paula Poundstone — quotation listed on her Wikiquote page (no specific primary publication cited). |
More Quotes by Paula
Add to List
