"The real problem is not why some pious, humble, believing people suffer, but why some do not"
About this Quote
Lewis flips the usual complaint about God on its head with the neat confidence of someone who knows exactly where modern outrage wants to go. We tend to treat suffering as the scandal that puts faith on trial: if good people hurt, either God is absent or the universe is rigged. Lewis refuses the frame. His pivot - not why some suffer, but why some do not - is less a clever paradox than a moral ambush. It drags the reader from the courtroom (where we prosecute God) into the mirror (where we examine our entitlement).
The subtext is Augustinian and bracing: if the world is broken and the human heart is bent, the surprising datum isn’t pain but mercy. Lewis is not romanticizing suffering; he’s attacking the assumption that comfort is the baseline state the cosmos owes us. By making the "real problem" the existence of unearned ease, he implies that what we call "normal life" is already a gift - and that our moral accounting is skewed by privilege, luck, and a selective memory of how precarious existence actually is.
Context matters: Lewis wrote as a Christian apologist shaped by two world wars and, later, personal grief. In a century that industrialized catastrophe, he’s wary of tidy theodicies and more interested in puncturing the modern habit of treating happiness as a right. The line works because it weaponizes humility: it doesn’t answer the question of suffering so much as reorder the questions we feel permitted to ask.
The subtext is Augustinian and bracing: if the world is broken and the human heart is bent, the surprising datum isn’t pain but mercy. Lewis is not romanticizing suffering; he’s attacking the assumption that comfort is the baseline state the cosmos owes us. By making the "real problem" the existence of unearned ease, he implies that what we call "normal life" is already a gift - and that our moral accounting is skewed by privilege, luck, and a selective memory of how precarious existence actually is.
Context matters: Lewis wrote as a Christian apologist shaped by two world wars and, later, personal grief. In a century that industrialized catastrophe, he’s wary of tidy theodicies and more interested in puncturing the modern habit of treating happiness as a right. The line works because it weaponizes humility: it doesn’t answer the question of suffering so much as reorder the questions we feel permitted to ask.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|---|
| Source | C. S. Lewis, The Problem of Pain (1940) — commonly cited source for the line: "The real problem is not why some pious, humble, believing people suffer, but why some do not." |
More Quotes by S. Lewis
Add to List
