"The shortest answer is doing the thing"
About this Quote
Hemingway’s line is a dare disguised as advice: stop auditioning for competence and just act. “The shortest answer” sounds like a tidy quip, but it carries his whole aesthetic program. He distrusted ornament, explanation, and the kind of self-justifying talk that turns fear into philosophy. If you want an “answer” to whether you can write, love, endure, or be brave, the proof isn’t a clever argument. It’s the doing.
The subtext is slightly abrasive, even moralistic. Hemingway isn’t offering comfort; he’s calling out delay. “Doing the thing” is blunt to the point of comedy, like a parent cutting through a child’s excuses. That bluntness matters because it frames action as the only language that can’t lie. Words can be strategic, evasive, performative. Action exposes you.
Contextually, it fits a writer who built a public persona around discipline, risk, and a suspicion of “bull.” In the Hemingway universe, courage is less a feeling than a behavior, shown under pressure. That’s also why the line lands now, in a culture that rewards announcing plans more than executing them. We’ve gotten good at narrating our intentions; Hemingway insists intentions don’t count as evidence.
There’s irony here too: a novelist, a professional maker of sentences, claiming the best answer is beyond sentences. It’s not anti-language so much as a warning about language’s temptations. Write the paragraph. Make the call. Show up. The rest is commentary.
The subtext is slightly abrasive, even moralistic. Hemingway isn’t offering comfort; he’s calling out delay. “Doing the thing” is blunt to the point of comedy, like a parent cutting through a child’s excuses. That bluntness matters because it frames action as the only language that can’t lie. Words can be strategic, evasive, performative. Action exposes you.
Contextually, it fits a writer who built a public persona around discipline, risk, and a suspicion of “bull.” In the Hemingway universe, courage is less a feeling than a behavior, shown under pressure. That’s also why the line lands now, in a culture that rewards announcing plans more than executing them. We’ve gotten good at narrating our intentions; Hemingway insists intentions don’t count as evidence.
There’s irony here too: a novelist, a professional maker of sentences, claiming the best answer is beyond sentences. It’s not anti-language so much as a warning about language’s temptations. Write the paragraph. Make the call. Show up. The rest is commentary.
Quote Details
| Topic | Motivational |
|---|
More Quotes by Ernest
Add to List








