"The thing generally raised on city land is taxes"
About this Quote
A dry, economical quip by Charles Dudley Warner lands a double entendre with perfect aim. To "raise" something on land usually means to grow crops; in the city, the only reliable harvest is higher tax bills. The joke rests on the gap between agrarian productivity and urban extraction, swapping the image of fields for the ledger book. It crystallizes the feeling that city land, instead of yielding food or tangible goods, chiefly yields obligations to the treasury.
Warner, Mark Twain’s friend and collaborator on The Gilded Age, had a sharp eye for the way money and politics mingle in bustling American cities. In the late nineteenth century, urban populations were exploding, municipal services were expanding, and political machines often siphoned funds through public works. Property taxes were the backbone of city finance, keyed to assessed values that rose with speculation and infrastructural booms. The line captures a citizen’s suspicion that, no matter how thriving the metropolis, the surest growth sector is the one printed on the tax bill.
Beneath the wit is a critique of incentives. When governance is structured to treat land chiefly as a revenue base, policy priorities can skew toward assessment over amenity, extraction over cultivation. The remark also brushes against Henry George’s contemporaneous debates about taxing land value rather than improvements, a way to discourage speculation while funding public goods. Warner’s skepticism echoes every time a neighborhood gentrifies, assessments spike, and long-time residents feel harvested rather than served.
Yet the sting of the epigram does not deny that taxes fund the very urban systems that make cities livable: water, transit, schools, safety, parks. The point is not that tax is illegitimate, but that city land should first raise life, opportunity, and shared prosperity. When the fiscal tail wags the urban dog, the city forgets its purpose. Warner’s one-line harvest warning urges stewards of the metropolis to grow more than receipts.
Warner, Mark Twain’s friend and collaborator on The Gilded Age, had a sharp eye for the way money and politics mingle in bustling American cities. In the late nineteenth century, urban populations were exploding, municipal services were expanding, and political machines often siphoned funds through public works. Property taxes were the backbone of city finance, keyed to assessed values that rose with speculation and infrastructural booms. The line captures a citizen’s suspicion that, no matter how thriving the metropolis, the surest growth sector is the one printed on the tax bill.
Beneath the wit is a critique of incentives. When governance is structured to treat land chiefly as a revenue base, policy priorities can skew toward assessment over amenity, extraction over cultivation. The remark also brushes against Henry George’s contemporaneous debates about taxing land value rather than improvements, a way to discourage speculation while funding public goods. Warner’s skepticism echoes every time a neighborhood gentrifies, assessments spike, and long-time residents feel harvested rather than served.
Yet the sting of the epigram does not deny that taxes fund the very urban systems that make cities livable: water, transit, schools, safety, parks. The point is not that tax is illegitimate, but that city land should first raise life, opportunity, and shared prosperity. When the fiscal tail wags the urban dog, the city forgets its purpose. Warner’s one-line harvest warning urges stewards of the metropolis to grow more than receipts.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Charles
Add to List
