"There's a victory, and defeat; the first and best of victories, the lowest and worst of defeats which each man gains or sustains at the hands not of another, but of himself"
About this Quote
Plato’s line is a trapdoor under the ordinary scoreboard of politics, war, and status. He concedes the crowd’s vocabulary - victory, defeat - then quietly reroutes it inward, where it becomes harder to fake and impossible to outsource. The “first and best” victory isn’t the headline win over an enemy; it’s the private conquest of appetite, fear, and self-deception. Likewise, the “lowest and worst” defeat isn’t being outplayed by rivals; it’s the surrender of one’s own reason to impulse. In Plato’s moral universe, the real battlefield is the soul, and external success can actually be evidence of internal collapse.
The intent is disciplinary: to re-educate ambition. Plato is writing in a culture intoxicated by honor, competition, and public reputation, and in the shadow of Athens’ civic failures - demagoguery, imperial overreach, the execution of Socrates. Against that backdrop, he treats self-mastery as the only stable form of freedom. If you can be bribed by pleasure, bullied by anger, or seduced by praise, you are not a citizen so much as a puppet.
The subtext is also political. A city can’t outgrow the character of the people who run it. Plato is arguing that the health of a democracy (or any regime) depends less on institutional mechanics than on whether individuals can govern themselves. His brilliance is framing ethics as strategy: the decisive opponent is you, and the decisive prize is control of your own mind.
The intent is disciplinary: to re-educate ambition. Plato is writing in a culture intoxicated by honor, competition, and public reputation, and in the shadow of Athens’ civic failures - demagoguery, imperial overreach, the execution of Socrates. Against that backdrop, he treats self-mastery as the only stable form of freedom. If you can be bribed by pleasure, bullied by anger, or seduced by praise, you are not a citizen so much as a puppet.
The subtext is also political. A city can’t outgrow the character of the people who run it. Plato is arguing that the health of a democracy (or any regime) depends less on institutional mechanics than on whether individuals can govern themselves. His brilliance is framing ethics as strategy: the decisive opponent is you, and the decisive prize is control of your own mind.
Quote Details
| Topic | Self-Discipline |
|---|
More Quotes by Plato
Add to List
