"They certainly did. They tried to make her look like a "nut case" and they succeeded to some extent"
About this Quote
A good editor’s menace is that he can make reputations sound like diagnoses. Bradlee’s line lands with the offhand certainty of someone describing a successful operation: “They certainly did.” No suspense, no hypotheticals, just a verdict. The real sting is in the casual bureaucratic “they” - an anonymous power bloc - and the euphemistic “to some extent,” which functions like a wink at the reader: the smear worked enough to do damage, not enough to be fully believed, and that’s often the sweet spot.
The phrase “make her look like a ‘nut case’” is doing double duty. It’s blunt, vernacular, and quoted, suggesting Bradlee is repeating the weaponized label as it circulated in newsrooms, political shops, or whispered briefings. By putting it in scare quotes, he signals skepticism while admitting the potency of the frame. “Nut case” isn’t an argument; it’s a shortcut that converts dissent, vulnerability, or complexity into disqualifying instability. It’s also conspicuously gendered in practice: “her” matters. Historically, women who challenge institutions are likelier to be pathologized rather than debated.
Contextually, this is Bradlee speaking from inside the machinery that both resists and inadvertently amplifies such narratives. The sentence structure mirrors media reality: a campaign (“they tried”) followed by outcome metrics (“they succeeded”). The subtext is a quiet indictment of how perception management beats facts - and how even sophisticated audiences can be nudged into treating character assassination as common sense.
The phrase “make her look like a ‘nut case’” is doing double duty. It’s blunt, vernacular, and quoted, suggesting Bradlee is repeating the weaponized label as it circulated in newsrooms, political shops, or whispered briefings. By putting it in scare quotes, he signals skepticism while admitting the potency of the frame. “Nut case” isn’t an argument; it’s a shortcut that converts dissent, vulnerability, or complexity into disqualifying instability. It’s also conspicuously gendered in practice: “her” matters. Historically, women who challenge institutions are likelier to be pathologized rather than debated.
Contextually, this is Bradlee speaking from inside the machinery that both resists and inadvertently amplifies such narratives. The sentence structure mirrors media reality: a campaign (“they tried”) followed by outcome metrics (“they succeeded”). The subtext is a quiet indictment of how perception management beats facts - and how even sophisticated audiences can be nudged into treating character assassination as common sense.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|
More Quotes by Ben
Add to List




