"Tradition does not mean that the living are dead, it means that the dead are living"
- Harold MacMillan
About this Quote
The quote by Harold MacMillan, "Tradition does not mean that the living are dead, it means that the dead are living," uses a thought-provoking reflection on the nature of custom and its function in society. In the beginning glance, it appears to juxtapose the states of living and being dead, attributing life to what is ostensibly past and gone. However, a deeper interpretation exposes a profound understanding of how customs operate as a bridge in between the past and present.
Traditions are typically viewed as a set of practices, beliefs, or custom-mades bied far from one generation to the next. On the surface, they can be perceived as troublesome or as relics that hinder development, recommending that those who follow them are not genuinely living in the present but are rather bound by the shackles of the past. This is where the concept that "the living are dead" may enter into play, as it suggests that those who slavishly adhere to tradition without understanding or adaptation may not be fully engaging with today.
Nevertheless, MacMillan's viewpoint provides a more positive view. By stating "the dead are living," he recommends that when we engage with customs, we are not just preserving remnants of the past; we are enlivening them. Through traditions, the voices, thoughts, and values of those who came before us persist into today. In this sense, customs are dynamic; they evolve as we reinterpret them and discover new meaning within them, allowing the "dead" to contribute to and shape contemporary life.
By keeping traditions alive, we allow them to inform our understanding of identity, culture, and morality. They end up being living discussions between generations, offering continuity and connection. In this way, MacMillan's quote encapsulates the idea that customs are not fixed monoliths to the dead, but living legacies that continue to motivate, inform, and direct us. This analysis motivates us to engage with customs not as passive recipients, but as active participants, bringing the past into the present to much better shape our future.
About the Author