"U.S. journalists I don't think are very courageous. They tend to go along with the government's policy domestically and internationally. To question is seen as being unpatriotic, or potentially subversive"
About this Quote
Fisk is doing what he always did best: turning the spotlight back on the storytellers and asking who, exactly, they’re working for. The line isn’t just a slap at American journalism; it’s an accusation about the incentives that shape it. “Courageous” here doesn’t mean daring in the Hollywood sense. It means willing to absorb institutional punishment: lost access, editor blowback, patriotic heckling, the quiet career frost that follows when you stop repeating the approved script.
The phrasing is surgical. “Tend to go along” is damning precisely because it’s modest; Fisk isn’t alleging a smoky conspiracy, he’s describing a culture of compliance that can feel like common sense inside a newsroom. The real charge sits in his causality: questioning policy gets translated into questioning the nation. That’s the trap. When dissent is framed as “unpatriotic,” the reporter’s job - skepticism - becomes a character flaw. “Potentially subversive” evokes the old American panic button, from McCarthyism to post-9/11 security rhetoric, where suspicion is a tool of governance and self-censorship becomes a civic virtue.
Context matters. Fisk’s career was built in war zones and in the long shadow of Western intervention in the Middle East; he watched official narratives harden into headlines, then harden again into justification. So the intent isn’t performative contrarianism. It’s a warning about how democracies manage consent: not by banning questions, but by making the questioner socially radioactive.
The phrasing is surgical. “Tend to go along” is damning precisely because it’s modest; Fisk isn’t alleging a smoky conspiracy, he’s describing a culture of compliance that can feel like common sense inside a newsroom. The real charge sits in his causality: questioning policy gets translated into questioning the nation. That’s the trap. When dissent is framed as “unpatriotic,” the reporter’s job - skepticism - becomes a character flaw. “Potentially subversive” evokes the old American panic button, from McCarthyism to post-9/11 security rhetoric, where suspicion is a tool of governance and self-censorship becomes a civic virtue.
Context matters. Fisk’s career was built in war zones and in the long shadow of Western intervention in the Middle East; he watched official narratives harden into headlines, then harden again into justification. So the intent isn’t performative contrarianism. It’s a warning about how democracies manage consent: not by banning questions, but by making the questioner socially radioactive.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List
