"We don't really need reviewers, just first-night reporters who will tell us faithfully whether or not the audience liked the show"
About this Quote
A gentle grenade lobbed at the gatekeepers of taste, Carroll O'Connor's line isn’t anti-intellectual so much as anti-pretension. He’s not arguing that criticism is useless; he’s arguing that a certain kind of criticism has confused authority with accuracy. The "reviewer" in his framing is the self-appointed high priest, arriving with a private rubric and leaving with a verdict. The "first-night reporter" is almost comically modest by comparison: just tell us what happened in the room. Did it land? Did it die? Did people lean forward or check their watches?
The intent is pragmatic, even protective. O'Connor spent a career in a medium where success is brutally empirical: ratings, laughter, letters, cancellations. In that world, the critic can feel like someone grading a storm. His phrase "faithfully" is doing heavy work; it’s a plea for an honest dispatch instead of a performance of superiority. The subtext: the audience is already the real tribunal, and critics sometimes write as if their job is to overrule that jury.
Context matters. O'Connor, forever entangled with the cultural crossfire around Archie Bunker, knew how critical consensus can miss the social function of a show: to provoke, to comfort, to start fights at the dinner table. He’s also winking at the industry’s premiere-night ritual, when everyone pretends a single review can decide a work’s fate. The line flatters the crowd, yes, but it also exposes the anxiety underneath: art wants legitimacy, entertainment wants proof, and critics too often sell certainty instead of witness.
The intent is pragmatic, even protective. O'Connor spent a career in a medium where success is brutally empirical: ratings, laughter, letters, cancellations. In that world, the critic can feel like someone grading a storm. His phrase "faithfully" is doing heavy work; it’s a plea for an honest dispatch instead of a performance of superiority. The subtext: the audience is already the real tribunal, and critics sometimes write as if their job is to overrule that jury.
Context matters. O'Connor, forever entangled with the cultural crossfire around Archie Bunker, knew how critical consensus can miss the social function of a show: to provoke, to comfort, to start fights at the dinner table. He’s also winking at the industry’s premiere-night ritual, when everyone pretends a single review can decide a work’s fate. The line flatters the crowd, yes, but it also exposes the anxiety underneath: art wants legitimacy, entertainment wants proof, and critics too often sell certainty instead of witness.
Quote Details
| Topic | Movie |
|---|
More Quotes by Carroll
Add to List
