"We've had a long wrangle with the pharmaceutical industry about parallel imports, and what we were saying is we want to make medicines and drugs as affordable as a possible to what is largely a poor population"
About this Quote
A bureaucratic phrase like "long wrangle" does quiet rhetorical work: it makes a bruising power struggle sound like tedious paperwork, the kind of dispute responsible adults have behind closed doors. That restraint is deliberate. Mbeki is casting the South African state not as a firebrand but as the patient custodian of public welfare, stuck negotiating with an industry that can out-lawyer and outspend governments. In the late-1990s and early-2000s, "parallel imports" was the technocratic code for something morally explosive: breaking the pricing chokehold created by patent-protected medicines, especially as HIV/AIDS ravaged poor communities.
The intent is to frame the fight as common sense, not ideology. "We want to make medicines... as affordable as possible" is plainspoken, almost disarmingly modest, a way to pre-empt accusations of theft, socialism, or hostility to innovation. Yet the subtext is confrontational: if affordability is the stated goal, then anyone resisting it becomes the obstacle to health. The phrase "largely a poor population" anchors the argument in distributive justice and national sovereignty, insisting that market logic cannot be the final arbiter when the consumer base is structurally unable to pay.
Context sharpens the stakes. South Africa faced international pressure, trade threats, and industry lawsuits over drug access. Mbeki's language tries to keep legitimacy on his side: not a crusade against pharma, but a government doing what governments are for when the market fails catastrophically. The tragedy, of course, is that Mbeki's broader AIDS-era legacy is tangled with denialism; here, he sounds like a leader fluent in the politics of access, even as the surrounding policy choices often undermined the very lives this sentence invokes.
The intent is to frame the fight as common sense, not ideology. "We want to make medicines... as affordable as possible" is plainspoken, almost disarmingly modest, a way to pre-empt accusations of theft, socialism, or hostility to innovation. Yet the subtext is confrontational: if affordability is the stated goal, then anyone resisting it becomes the obstacle to health. The phrase "largely a poor population" anchors the argument in distributive justice and national sovereignty, insisting that market logic cannot be the final arbiter when the consumer base is structurally unable to pay.
Context sharpens the stakes. South Africa faced international pressure, trade threats, and industry lawsuits over drug access. Mbeki's language tries to keep legitimacy on his side: not a crusade against pharma, but a government doing what governments are for when the market fails catastrophically. The tragedy, of course, is that Mbeki's broader AIDS-era legacy is tangled with denialism; here, he sounds like a leader fluent in the politics of access, even as the surrounding policy choices often undermined the very lives this sentence invokes.
Quote Details
| Topic | Health |
|---|
More Quotes by Thabo
Add to List
