"What clever man has ever needed to commit a crime? Crime is the last resort of political half-wits"
About this Quote
Talleyrand scoffs at the resort to crime as a confession of political incompetence. Power secured by finesse does not need the blunt instrument of illegality; it relies on timing, persuasion, bargaining, and the careful use of appearances. Crime, by contrast, is a shortcut taken when imagination fails. It yields immediate results but destroys legitimacy, invites retaliation, and narrows one’s options thereafter. The clever politician arranges circumstances so that desired outcomes emerge through lawful forms and the consent or at least acquiescence of others.
The line gains bite from the speaker’s career. Talleyrand served the ancien regime, the Revolution, Napoleon, the Restoration, and the July Monarchy, surviving and shaping each turn by subtle calculation. At the Congress of Vienna he won strikingly favorable terms for defeated France without force, trading on credibility, moderation, and the balance of interests. He prized procedure and form not as moral absolutes but as instruments that make victories durable. His famous counsel, above all, no excessive zeal, complements the present maxim: zealots reach for extremes, including repression and bloodshed, when patience and craft would do.
His era abounds with examples. The Terror’s guillotine and Napoleon’s most brazen acts, such as the seizure and execution of the Duc d’Enghien, gained momentary control but seeded their own undoing by outraging opinion and alienating allies. Talleyrand’s aphorism reads as a rebuke to such crude displays. It also contains a sly self-portrait. He was accused of corruption and treachery, yet he insisted on operating behind a veil of legality and deniability. The point is not moral purity but efficacy: crimes remove constraints in the short term while eroding the very architecture that sustains power.
The lesson is enduring. Political intelligence is measured by the ability to make others want what you want, to convert private schemes into public policy, and to do so within the rules. When force or crime becomes necessary, the higher art has already failed.
The line gains bite from the speaker’s career. Talleyrand served the ancien regime, the Revolution, Napoleon, the Restoration, and the July Monarchy, surviving and shaping each turn by subtle calculation. At the Congress of Vienna he won strikingly favorable terms for defeated France without force, trading on credibility, moderation, and the balance of interests. He prized procedure and form not as moral absolutes but as instruments that make victories durable. His famous counsel, above all, no excessive zeal, complements the present maxim: zealots reach for extremes, including repression and bloodshed, when patience and craft would do.
His era abounds with examples. The Terror’s guillotine and Napoleon’s most brazen acts, such as the seizure and execution of the Duc d’Enghien, gained momentary control but seeded their own undoing by outraging opinion and alienating allies. Talleyrand’s aphorism reads as a rebuke to such crude displays. It also contains a sly self-portrait. He was accused of corruption and treachery, yet he insisted on operating behind a veil of legality and deniability. The point is not moral purity but efficacy: crimes remove constraints in the short term while eroding the very architecture that sustains power.
The lesson is enduring. Political intelligence is measured by the ability to make others want what you want, to convert private schemes into public policy, and to do so within the rules. When force or crime becomes necessary, the higher art has already failed.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Charles
Add to List
