"While I was pleasantly surprised by the relatively high number of jobs created in April, the fact is that job creation during this recovery period has significantly lagged both historical experience in recovery, and the projections of the Bush Administration"
About this Quote
“Pleasantly surprised” is the sugar that helps the medicine go down. Barney Frank opens with a calibrated nod to good news, not because he’s feeling generous, but because he’s inoculating himself against the predictable counterattack: that Democrats can’t admit progress, that any criticism is reflexive. The real payload lands immediately after: “the fact is.” It’s courtroom language, a gavel-tap meant to drag the conversation away from a single month’s headline number and back to the longer, uglier graph.
The quote is doing two things at once. First, it reframes the metric. April’s jobs report becomes a blip inside “this recovery period,” a phrase that widens the time horizon and invites comparison to past recoveries. Frank’s point isn’t that April didn’t matter; it’s that the recovery’s pace fails the historical smell test. Second, it weaponizes the Bush Administration’s own expectations: “and the projections.” That’s not just a policy critique, it’s a credibility trap. If the administration sold a recovery story with optimistic forecasts, then lagging job creation isn’t merely unfortunate; it’s a broken promise.
The subtext is pure political jiu-jitsu: don’t argue over whether the economy is improving, argue over whether the improvement is acceptable and who oversold it. Frank’s syntax performs moderation while delivering indictment. He positions himself as empirically fair-minded, then uses that pose to justify a harsher conclusion: this isn’t a triumph; it’s underperformance, and the people in charge set the bar they’re now failing.
The quote is doing two things at once. First, it reframes the metric. April’s jobs report becomes a blip inside “this recovery period,” a phrase that widens the time horizon and invites comparison to past recoveries. Frank’s point isn’t that April didn’t matter; it’s that the recovery’s pace fails the historical smell test. Second, it weaponizes the Bush Administration’s own expectations: “and the projections.” That’s not just a policy critique, it’s a credibility trap. If the administration sold a recovery story with optimistic forecasts, then lagging job creation isn’t merely unfortunate; it’s a broken promise.
The subtext is pure political jiu-jitsu: don’t argue over whether the economy is improving, argue over whether the improvement is acceptable and who oversold it. Frank’s syntax performs moderation while delivering indictment. He positions himself as empirically fair-minded, then uses that pose to justify a harsher conclusion: this isn’t a triumph; it’s underperformance, and the people in charge set the bar they’re now failing.
Quote Details
| Topic | Work |
|---|
More Quotes by Barney
Add to List
