"Writers are not meant for action"
About this Quote
The line sounds like a retreat from the barricades, but it is also a credo about the craft. Writers work by watching, listening, and arranging; they proceed by indirection, sifting gestures, fantasies, and voices until something truer than reportage takes shape. Manuel Puig built his novels from the textures of popular culture, from film scripts, gossip, radio serials, and melodrama. That sensibility distrusts heroic postures. Action, in the romantic sense, is a clean arc; life, as he renders it, is a collage of fragments, desires, and contradictions. To choose the collage is to refuse the swagger of immediate intervention.
The claim carries a biographical edge. As an Argentine living through years of repression and exile, Puig did not enlist in militant politics or celebrate violence. He gravitated instead to the subversive possibilities of storytelling and camp, where sensitivity itself becomes a mode of critique. The Kiss of the Spider Woman stages this belief: two prisoners pass the time with movies retold and fantasies spun, and yet those stories do not escape reality; they rewire it. Narrative becomes a medium for tenderness, persuasion, and dissent, invisible to the guards who police only overt acts. If writers are not meant for action, it is because their strongest tool is not the deed but the reconfiguration of what can be imagined.
There is also irony in the statement. To say that writers are not meant for action is to argue that language can intervene without marching boots. It questions the machismo that equates effectiveness with force, proposing that the deep work of culture happens in the slow alteration of feeling and form. Puig treats attention as a political virtue and artifice as a moral stance. No slogans, no manifestos, only the persistent pressure of stories that make other lives thinkable. The novels do not halt tanks; they make the need to halt them intelligible, and perhaps unbearable to ignore.
The claim carries a biographical edge. As an Argentine living through years of repression and exile, Puig did not enlist in militant politics or celebrate violence. He gravitated instead to the subversive possibilities of storytelling and camp, where sensitivity itself becomes a mode of critique. The Kiss of the Spider Woman stages this belief: two prisoners pass the time with movies retold and fantasies spun, and yet those stories do not escape reality; they rewire it. Narrative becomes a medium for tenderness, persuasion, and dissent, invisible to the guards who police only overt acts. If writers are not meant for action, it is because their strongest tool is not the deed but the reconfiguration of what can be imagined.
There is also irony in the statement. To say that writers are not meant for action is to argue that language can intervene without marching boots. It questions the machismo that equates effectiveness with force, proposing that the deep work of culture happens in the slow alteration of feeling and form. Puig treats attention as a political virtue and artifice as a moral stance. No slogans, no manifestos, only the persistent pressure of stories that make other lives thinkable. The novels do not halt tanks; they make the need to halt them intelligible, and perhaps unbearable to ignore.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by Manuel
Add to List
