Introduction
"Culture and Imperialism" by Edward Said, published in 1993, is a critical work that takes a look at the complex relationship between culture and imperialism. Said, a prominent literary critic and intellectual born in Jerusalem, is best understood for his groundbreaking book "Orientalism" (1978), which critiqued Western understandings of the Middle East and Asia. "Culture and Imperialism" broadens upon the conversations initiated in "Orientalism" and checks out the methods which literature, culture, and intellectual discourse have actually been instrumental in forming and justifying imperialism.
Stories of Empire
Said focuses on the analysis of European and American literature, primarily from the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, to expose how these works both reflected and perpetuated imperialist ideologies. He argues that many canonical works, such as those by Jane Austen, Joseph Conrad, and E.M. Forster, include underlying narratives of empire that are often neglected by critics and readers. For example, Said shows how Austen's "Mansfield Park" is reliant on the West Indian plantation to which the protagonist's household owes their wealth and status, highlighting the inevitable connection in between the English countryside and its colonial territories.
In his readings of Conrad's "Heart of Darkness" and Forster's "A Passage to India", Said demonstrates the ways in which these novels offer a fuller photo of the imperial experience, providing both the oppressors and the oppressed. Contrary to the prevailing belief that these novels are anti-imperialistic, Said argues that they eventually reinforce imperialist concepts by specifying the colonized individuals as inferior and incapable of self-governance.
Resistance and Counter-Narratives
Said asserts that cultural resistance versus imperialism has been a common function of the colonized individuals's history. This resistance is exhibited by the emergence of postcolonial literature produced by writers such as Chinua Achebe, Ngũgĩ wa Thiong'o, and Salman Rushdie. These authors challenge and subvert the master narratives of imperialism, exposing the intrinsic contradictions and oppressions present in these historical accounts.
However, Said argues that resistance ought to not be restricted to the production of postcolonial literature, but ought to also encompass the re-appropriation of Western literary and cultural texts. He competes that checking out "against the grain" of canonical works, revealing their imperialist presumptions, and examining their complicated relationship with colonial discourse are essential to taking apart imperialist ideologies.
Overlapping Territories and Intertwined Histories
Said introduces the concept of "contrapuntal reading", the synchronised assessment of both the colonizer's and the colonized's viewpoints, as a vital approach for comprehending the complex relationship in between culture and imperialism. This technique highlights the level to which imperial discourse is woven into the material of Western society, regardless of the Western world's regular disavowal of royal history.
Drawing on the works of numerous theorists and scholars, including Antonio Gramsci and Michel Foucault, Said stresses that the analysis of culture and imperialism need to take into account the overlapping areas and intertwined histories of varied people and locations. He contends that the borders in between the colonizer and the colonized are far from fixed which the exchange of power and influence in between them is ongoing and continuous.
Conclusion
"Culture and Imperialism" is a substantial work that re-positions the discussion on imperialism by examining the role of literature and culture in shaping it. Edward Said's analysis of canonical literary works reveals the level to which imperialist ideologies have been instilled in Western thought.
His insistence on counter-narratives and contrapuntal reading as approaches of resistance highlights the ever-evolving characteristics of imperialism and the value of magnifying marginalized voices to develop a more fair discourse. The book continues to be a touchstone for scholars and students working on postcolonial literature, theory, and cultural studies.
Culture and Imperialism
Culture and Imperialism highlights the ways in which culture and art are used by Western societies to justify, sustain, and maintain their colonial and imperial objectives. Said explores the role that literature, music, and the arts play in influencing and perpetuating the colonial mindset.
Author: Edward Said
Edward Said, a Palestinian-American writer and influential figure in postcolonial studies & literary criticism.
More about Edward Said