Title: Je suis Pierre Rivière (1976)
Background:"Je suis Pierre Rivière" is a 1976 French crime movie directed by René Allio and based upon the real story rebuilded in Michel Foucault's book, "I, Pierre Rivière, having actually slaughtered my mother, my sibling, and my brother ...". The film provides an unsettling account of a triple patricide dedicated by a young peasant in the 19th-century Normandy countryside.
Property:The story begins with Pierre Rivière, a psychologically unsteady Normandian peasant who is misinterpreted and ignored in his rural neighborhood mostly due to his strange habits and inability to conform to societal norms. Gradually, Pierre ends up being increasingly resentful towards his mother, who is physically abusive and neglectful towards him. His household lives in extreme hardship, leading to a troubled domestic situation that even more worsens Pierre's weakening mental health.
Eliminating His Family:In an act of brutal violence, Pierre Rivière murders his mother, bro, and sis with a pruning hook. He devotes this unthinkable show a chilling sense of calm and a proof of careful preparation, revealing the depth of his derangement. After the murders, he flees to the woods and writes a memoir detailing his motives for the criminal activity, his breaking down mental state, and brutal living conditions that led him to this point.
Capture and Trial:Eventually, Pierre is caught and brought to trial. Regardless of his admission and justification of the criminal activity, he presents a puzzle for the legal authorities, doctors, and regional community. The court struggles to reconcile the contradictions of the law, religion, and growing psychiatric theories, shown in Pierre's case.
Conclusion:The movie utilizes a series of flashbacks to look into Pierre's past, his mindset, and the intention behind his criminal activity. The court stops working to discover a sufficient description for Pierre's violent act according to the legal, medical, and psychiatric discourses of the period. Meanwhile, most of the neighborhood view him as a madman. "Je suis Pierre Rivière" ends with Pierre's execution, leaving the audiences with an unresolvable paradox.
Analysis:Allio's film is remarkable for its striking and emotionally separated portrayal of its subject's aberrant mindset. It successfully integrates cinematic storytelling with historic reenactment, exposing the complexities of criminal insanity, the impact of cruelty, the lethargy of rural poverty, and the restrictions of a legal system faced with a crime of such enormity and inexplicability.
Movie's Impact:"Je suis Pierre Rivière" is not just about a historical crime, but also acts as a commentary on the discourses of law, faith, and psychiatry in society. The film connects the audience to the late 18th-century pastoral landscape, highlighting the historical context of the crime, and leaves us with a contemplative sense of melancholy and perplexity. It sensitively represents the dichotomy of peace of mind and insanity, recommending that society's understanding and treatment of mental disorder are yet to be totally realized or adequately dealt with.
Top Cast
