"A decision is what a man makes when he can't find anybody to serve on a committee"
About this Quote
Fletcher Knebel's quote, "A decision is what a man makes when he can't find anybody to serve on a committee", offers a funny yet incisive commentary on the nature of decision-making, particularly within governmental or organizational contexts. At its core, this statement shows a doubtful view of collective decision-making processes, potentially recommending that individuals frequently turn to forming committees as a way to diffuse obligation and prevent the problem of making difficult choices alone.
Committees, in various organizational structures, are typically formed to harness the diverse point of views and know-how of their members. Nevertheless, Knebel suggests that this procedure can also work as an evasion tactic; when people are reluctant to make a conclusive decision, they assemble a group to share the weight of the repercussions. This phenomenon is not unusual in organizations where decision-making procedures can become slowed down in bureaucracy, resulting in "paralysis by analysis". When committees are formed, the process can certainly become drawn-out, with conversations dragging on as different viewpoints and interests are considered.
Knebel's quote can likewise be analyzed as a critique of the inefficiencies developed by over-reliance on committees. Frequently, the need of unanimous or bulk arrangement can cause compromises that please no one totally, therefore diluting the impact of potential solutions. In contrast, a single decision-maker, especially one who is decisive and notified, might possibly enact alter more swiftly and effectively.
Furthermore, this quote might motivate people to welcome responsibility and the responsibility of decision-making. It serves as an amusing suggestion that sometimes decisions need to be made without the comfort of consensus or the input of a committee. While group input can be important, Knebel implies that there are circumstances where the desire to make an independent choice is needed-- especially in minutes where cumulative formation is not practical. Ultimately, the quote motivates a balance between partnership and specific accountability, suggesting that both are vital for efficient leadership and governance.
About the Author