"After having dispatched a meal, I went ashore, and found no habitation save a single house, and that without an occupant; we had no doubt that the people had fled in terror at our approach, as the house was completely furnished"
About this Quote
Columbus narrates conquest the way a tourist reviews a disappointing Airbnb: ate, went ashore, noticed the decor. The casual sequencing is the point. By leading with “After having dispatched a meal,” he frames landfall as routine logistics, not a collision of worlds. Hunger is handled; now the shoreline can be handled too. The sentence moves with bureaucratic calm, as if the moral weather is clear.
The real work happens in the pivot from observation to certainty: “we had no doubt.” Columbus sees an empty, fully furnished house and converts it into evidence of fear. That leap is an early template for colonial storytelling: absence becomes confession. If the inhabitants aren’t present, it must be because they’re terrified; if they left possessions behind, it proves panic; if they’re scared, then the newcomers are already dominant. A gap in knowledge is patched with an assumption that flatters power.
“Found no habitation save a single house” is also a rhetorical shrinking ray. A community becomes a solitary structure, a landscape becomes sparse, available. Yet “completely furnished” betrays a different reality: domestic life, continuity, texture. Columbus registers the signs of a settled world and uses them to stage the opposite conclusion, not because he’s blind, but because the voyage’s logic demands it. Sponsorship, sovereignty, and profit require a narrative of discovery and submission, not one of meeting people with claims of their own.
Even the collective “we” matters: this isn’t a private diary of doubt; it’s a report calibrated to justify what comes next.
The real work happens in the pivot from observation to certainty: “we had no doubt.” Columbus sees an empty, fully furnished house and converts it into evidence of fear. That leap is an early template for colonial storytelling: absence becomes confession. If the inhabitants aren’t present, it must be because they’re terrified; if they left possessions behind, it proves panic; if they’re scared, then the newcomers are already dominant. A gap in knowledge is patched with an assumption that flatters power.
“Found no habitation save a single house” is also a rhetorical shrinking ray. A community becomes a solitary structure, a landscape becomes sparse, available. Yet “completely furnished” betrays a different reality: domestic life, continuity, texture. Columbus registers the signs of a settled world and uses them to stage the opposite conclusion, not because he’s blind, but because the voyage’s logic demands it. Sponsorship, sovereignty, and profit require a narrative of discovery and submission, not one of meeting people with claims of their own.
Even the collective “we” matters: this isn’t a private diary of doubt; it’s a report calibrated to justify what comes next.
Quote Details
| Topic | Travel |
|---|
More Quotes by Christopher
Add to List
