"Ah, but a man's reach should exceed his grasp, Or what's a heaven for?"
About this Quote
Ambition gets framed here as a kind of moral duty, not a personality quirk. Browning Hamilton’s line works because it refuses the tidy, self-help version of “know your limits.” It argues the opposite: a life constrained to what you can already hold is a life without altitude. “Reach” isn’t just desire; it’s extension, risk, the body leaning past its safe center of gravity. “Grasp” is possession, mastery, the comfortable inventory of what’s already secured. The sentence makes that gap - the distance between wanting and owning - feel not merely acceptable but necessary.
The pivot is the second clause, which smuggles theology into a practical ethic. “Or what’s a heaven for?” turns aspiration into evidence. Heaven, whether taken literally or as metaphor, becomes the horizon that justifies striving: the imagined ideal that keeps the human engine running. It’s slyly rhetorical, almost teasing. If you don’t attempt what you can’t guarantee, you’re treating the world like a closed system, as if there’s no “beyond” to aim at.
The context matters: a late-Victorian/early-20th-century writer living through industrial acceleration, imperial confidence, and then the brutal correction of world war. In that era, progress was both a creed and a gamble. The line captures the era’s optimism while quietly admitting its cost: you will fail to “grasp” plenty. The point is that the reaching is the measure of a life, and the unattained isn’t a verdict - it’s the proof you were aiming high enough.
The pivot is the second clause, which smuggles theology into a practical ethic. “Or what’s a heaven for?” turns aspiration into evidence. Heaven, whether taken literally or as metaphor, becomes the horizon that justifies striving: the imagined ideal that keeps the human engine running. It’s slyly rhetorical, almost teasing. If you don’t attempt what you can’t guarantee, you’re treating the world like a closed system, as if there’s no “beyond” to aim at.
The context matters: a late-Victorian/early-20th-century writer living through industrial acceleration, imperial confidence, and then the brutal correction of world war. In that era, progress was both a creed and a gamble. The line captures the era’s optimism while quietly admitting its cost: you will fail to “grasp” plenty. The point is that the reaching is the measure of a life, and the unattained isn’t a verdict - it’s the proof you were aiming high enough.
Quote Details
| Topic | Meaning of Life |
|---|---|
| Source | Later attribution: Unbuilt Hamilton (Mark Osbaldeston, 2016) modern compilationISBN: 9781459733008 · ID: ma7XCgAAQBAJ
Evidence: ... Ah, but a man's reach should exceed his grasp Or what's a heaven for? — Robert Browning, Andrea del Sarto. I. n more earnest, less ironic times, Hamilton used to call itself the Ambitious City. As a tool of civic boosterism, it's a ... Other candidates (1) George Washington (Robert Browning Hamilton) compilation38.3% ich to place human gods i should place washington on that pedestal as the most fi |
| Featured | This quote was our Quote of the Day on August 13, 2025 |
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List









