"All very successful commanders are prima donnas and must be so treated"
About this Quote
Patton isn’t confessing a vanity; he’s outlining a management doctrine built for war, where results are measured in territory taken and bodies spared. Calling successful commanders “prima donnas” is deliberately provocative: it borrows a term of theatrical fragility and applies it to the hyper-masculine world of generals. That friction is the point. Patton is saying the best battlefield leaders are not interchangeable functionaries. They are temperamental instruments, powered by ego, appetite for risk, and a fierce sense of personal destiny. You don’t sand that down; you aim it.
The subtext is practical and unsentimental. Armies run on hierarchy, but they also run on morale, audacity, and speed. A commander who believes he’s exceptional is more likely to act decisively, to impose clarity amid chaos, to project confidence that ripples down the chain of command. Patton’s twist is the second clause: “and must be so treated.” Success isn’t just a private psychological quirk; it’s something an institution has to accommodate. Flatter them, protect their quirks, give them latitude, stage-manage their public image. In exchange, you get momentum.
Context matters: Patton’s World War II was a coalition war under intense political scrutiny, where gifted commanders could be liabilities as much as assets. He himself was famously volatile, and his career depended on being both indulged and contained. The line doubles as self-justification and a warning to bureaucrats: if you want brilliance at the front, you can’t demand perfect comportment in the rear.
The subtext is practical and unsentimental. Armies run on hierarchy, but they also run on morale, audacity, and speed. A commander who believes he’s exceptional is more likely to act decisively, to impose clarity amid chaos, to project confidence that ripples down the chain of command. Patton’s twist is the second clause: “and must be so treated.” Success isn’t just a private psychological quirk; it’s something an institution has to accommodate. Flatter them, protect their quirks, give them latitude, stage-manage their public image. In exchange, you get momentum.
Context matters: Patton’s World War II was a coalition war under intense political scrutiny, where gifted commanders could be liabilities as much as assets. He himself was famously volatile, and his career depended on being both indulged and contained. The line doubles as self-justification and a warning to bureaucrats: if you want brilliance at the front, you can’t demand perfect comportment in the rear.
Quote Details
| Topic | Leadership |
|---|
More Quotes by George
Add to List
