"All we ask is to be let alone"
About this Quote
A sentence that pretends to be modest while asking for permission to keep power. Jefferson Davis's "All we ask is to be let alone" is rhetorically brilliant in the way it shrinks an aggressive political project into the posture of a besieged homeowner. The verb "ask" softens what was, in practice, a demand backed by secession, armies, and the insistence that millions of enslaved people remain unfree. "Let alone" borrows the language of personal privacy and neighborly boundaries, laundering a national rupture into something that sounds like basic etiquette.
The intent was strategic: frame the Confederacy as defensive, not rebellious, and cast the Union as the provocateur. It's a classic inversion move. If the South is merely trying to be left in peace, then federal action becomes meddling, even tyranny; the moral burden shifts onto Lincoln's government to justify force. Davis is also speaking to foreign audiences, especially Britain and France, who might be more inclined to recognize a state that looks like a victim of coercion than one built to preserve slavery.
The subtext, though, is that "alone" never meant isolation from the rest of the country; it meant autonomy to maintain a specific social order while still benefiting from markets, diplomacy, and territory. Most pointedly, it erases the people who could not be "let alone" under that order. The line works because it's compact, plausible, and emotionally legible. Its cruelty is in what it makes sound like common sense.
The intent was strategic: frame the Confederacy as defensive, not rebellious, and cast the Union as the provocateur. It's a classic inversion move. If the South is merely trying to be left in peace, then federal action becomes meddling, even tyranny; the moral burden shifts onto Lincoln's government to justify force. Davis is also speaking to foreign audiences, especially Britain and France, who might be more inclined to recognize a state that looks like a victim of coercion than one built to preserve slavery.
The subtext, though, is that "alone" never meant isolation from the rest of the country; it meant autonomy to maintain a specific social order while still benefiting from markets, diplomacy, and territory. Most pointedly, it erases the people who could not be "let alone" under that order. The line works because it's compact, plausible, and emotionally legible. Its cruelty is in what it makes sound like common sense.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Jefferson
Add to List








