"Children need models rather than critics"
About this Quote
Children learn by imitation long before they master reflection. They watch how adults handle anger, disagreement, boredom, and joy, and they absorb those patterns as permission slips for their own behavior. Telling a child not to lie while offering convenient half-truths at the door teaches deception more forcefully than any lecture. A calm apology after losing one’s temper teaches self-repair more convincingly than a warning about temper in the abstract. The model supplies a script, not just a rule.
Criticism, by contrast, often assumes that naming a fault will correct it. For developing minds, criticism without example can produce shame or defiance, and it rarely provides a pathway to different action. Children need to see the mechanics of patience, cooperation, and courage enacted in real situations. They need to witness an adult pausing before speaking, sharing credit, admitting error, persisting through tedium. Such moments build a tacit curriculum of habits that words alone cannot transmit.
Joseph Joubert, a French moralist of the late 18th and early 19th centuries, favored brief, precise reflections on the formation of character. Writing in the wake of revolution and restoration, he prized moderation and inner discipline when public life was often shrill and punitive. His admonition reflects that sensibility: culture improves when example precedes judgment, and authority draws strength not from severity but from congruence between speech and deed. His notebooks, polished into aphorisms and published posthumously, return again and again to this ideal of gentle guidance.
None of this rejects correction. Children benefit from boundaries and clear feedback. But correction becomes credible when it is anchored in lived practice and proximity: doing alongside, not merely saying from above. In a world saturated with commentary and ratings, the principle is timely. Less scolding, more demonstration. Fewer diagnoses of what is wrong, more modeling of what is possible. The adult who lives the lesson becomes the lesson, and the lesson is then likely to endure.
Criticism, by contrast, often assumes that naming a fault will correct it. For developing minds, criticism without example can produce shame or defiance, and it rarely provides a pathway to different action. Children need to see the mechanics of patience, cooperation, and courage enacted in real situations. They need to witness an adult pausing before speaking, sharing credit, admitting error, persisting through tedium. Such moments build a tacit curriculum of habits that words alone cannot transmit.
Joseph Joubert, a French moralist of the late 18th and early 19th centuries, favored brief, precise reflections on the formation of character. Writing in the wake of revolution and restoration, he prized moderation and inner discipline when public life was often shrill and punitive. His admonition reflects that sensibility: culture improves when example precedes judgment, and authority draws strength not from severity but from congruence between speech and deed. His notebooks, polished into aphorisms and published posthumously, return again and again to this ideal of gentle guidance.
None of this rejects correction. Children benefit from boundaries and clear feedback. But correction becomes credible when it is anchored in lived practice and proximity: doing alongside, not merely saying from above. In a world saturated with commentary and ratings, the principle is timely. Less scolding, more demonstration. Fewer diagnoses of what is wrong, more modeling of what is possible. The adult who lives the lesson becomes the lesson, and the lesson is then likely to endure.
Quote Details
| Topic | Parenting |
|---|
More Quotes by Joseph
Add to List
