"Crime butchers innocence to secure a throne, and innocence struggles with all its might against the attempts of crime"
About this Quote
Robespierre frames politics as a slaughterhouse where power is purchased in blood and justified as self-defense. “Crime butchers innocence to secure a throne” is a deliberately visceral inversion of monarchy’s favorite story about itself: that kings rule by divine right and maintain order. In his telling, the true original violence is at the top. The “throne” isn’t just Louis XVI’s chair; it’s the whole architecture of inherited authority, sustained by coercion while claiming legitimacy.
The second clause is the real trapdoor. “Innocence struggles with all its might” sounds like a moral fairy tale, but it’s also a preemptive alibi for escalation. If innocence is by nature embattled, then aggression can be recast as resistance, and severity becomes a form of virtue. Robespierre’s genius - and menace - is how he turns a binary into a mandate: either you are innocence fighting to live, or you are crime defending a throne. There’s no neutral ground, no mixed motives, no tragic complexity, only moral sorting.
Context sharpens the edge. This is Revolutionary France, where the new republic is besieged by foreign armies, royalist insurgencies, and factional sabotage. Robespierre’s rhetoric doesn’t merely describe that emergency; it manufactures clarity inside it. By casting opponents as “crime,” he creates the ethical conditions for extraordinary measures, including terror, to be read as reluctant necessity. The line works because it collapses political conflict into a myth of purity under assault - a story that can mobilize a crowd and silence a conscience in the same breath.
The second clause is the real trapdoor. “Innocence struggles with all its might” sounds like a moral fairy tale, but it’s also a preemptive alibi for escalation. If innocence is by nature embattled, then aggression can be recast as resistance, and severity becomes a form of virtue. Robespierre’s genius - and menace - is how he turns a binary into a mandate: either you are innocence fighting to live, or you are crime defending a throne. There’s no neutral ground, no mixed motives, no tragic complexity, only moral sorting.
Context sharpens the edge. This is Revolutionary France, where the new republic is besieged by foreign armies, royalist insurgencies, and factional sabotage. Robespierre’s rhetoric doesn’t merely describe that emergency; it manufactures clarity inside it. By casting opponents as “crime,” he creates the ethical conditions for extraordinary measures, including terror, to be read as reluctant necessity. The line works because it collapses political conflict into a myth of purity under assault - a story that can mobilize a crowd and silence a conscience in the same breath.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Maximilien
Add to List






