"Don't cut my throat, I may want to do that later myself"
About this Quote
A baseball lifer with a vaudevillian tongue, Casey Stengel turns desperation into a punchline: "Don't cut my throat, I may want to do that later myself". The joke lands because it flips the usual power dynamic. Instead of begging for mercy, he demands autonomy over his own downfall. It is gallows humor as a kind of clubhouse armor: if you can narrate your misfortune first, you deny hecklers, owners, and beat writers the satisfaction of doing it for you.
Stengel worked in a world where public failure was part of the job description. A manager is scapegoat-by-design, absorbing blame so the organization can pretend it has control. The line winks at that ritual. "Don't cut my throat" reads like a plea to the bosses or the press not to fire him, not to eviscerate him in print, not to make his humiliation official. The second half is the real sting: he is already entertaining the possibility that he will self-destruct, but on his schedule, with his own punchline. That is pride disguised as self-deprecation.
There is also a sly critique of how quickly sports culture turns on its own. Fans demand accountability, media demands a story, executives demand a clean narrative. Stengel answers with a refusal to be flattened into the day's villain. If he's going to be sacrificed, he'll at least get the last laugh - and in baseball, that can be the only leverage left.
Stengel worked in a world where public failure was part of the job description. A manager is scapegoat-by-design, absorbing blame so the organization can pretend it has control. The line winks at that ritual. "Don't cut my throat" reads like a plea to the bosses or the press not to fire him, not to eviscerate him in print, not to make his humiliation official. The second half is the real sting: he is already entertaining the possibility that he will self-destruct, but on his schedule, with his own punchline. That is pride disguised as self-deprecation.
There is also a sly critique of how quickly sports culture turns on its own. Fans demand accountability, media demands a story, executives demand a clean narrative. Stengel answers with a refusal to be flattened into the day's villain. If he's going to be sacrificed, he'll at least get the last laugh - and in baseball, that can be the only leverage left.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Casey
Add to List








