"Every man who rises above the common level has received two educations: the first from his teachers; the second, more personal and important, from himself"
About this Quote
Gibbon is quietly demoting the classroom without romanticizing ignorance. The line flatters formal education just enough to be polite, then pivots to the real prize: self-education as the engine of distinction. That pivot matters. In the 18th-century world Gibbon inhabited, schooling was a gatekeeping apparatus for elites, a credentialing ritual as much as an intellectual one. By saying the first education comes from teachers, he nods to the institution; by insisting the second is "more personal and important", he claims that institutions only supply raw material. The rest is temperament: curiosity, stamina, and the willingness to revise your own mind.
The subtext has bite. "Rises above the common level" is a loaded phrase in an era obsessed with rank; Gibbon reframes social ascent as cognitive ascent, earned not by birth but by disciplined self-fashioning. It's also an implicit critique of passive learning. Teachers can transmit knowledge, but they cannot confer judgment, taste, or synthesis - the higher-order skills that separate an informed person from a merely instructed one.
Context sharpens the intent. Gibbon's Decline and Fall is the product of voracious reading, skepticism toward inherited narratives, and a solitary capacity to connect dots across centuries. His "second education" is essentially the historian's method: turning facts into understanding through sustained private labor. The quote works because it offers a meritocratic myth with an Enlightenment edge: authority begins outside you, but intellectual authority is built, painfully, inside.
The subtext has bite. "Rises above the common level" is a loaded phrase in an era obsessed with rank; Gibbon reframes social ascent as cognitive ascent, earned not by birth but by disciplined self-fashioning. It's also an implicit critique of passive learning. Teachers can transmit knowledge, but they cannot confer judgment, taste, or synthesis - the higher-order skills that separate an informed person from a merely instructed one.
Context sharpens the intent. Gibbon's Decline and Fall is the product of voracious reading, skepticism toward inherited narratives, and a solitary capacity to connect dots across centuries. His "second education" is essentially the historian's method: turning facts into understanding through sustained private labor. The quote works because it offers a meritocratic myth with an Enlightenment edge: authority begins outside you, but intellectual authority is built, painfully, inside.
Quote Details
| Topic | Learning |
|---|
More Quotes by Edward
Add to List
