"For among other evils caused by being disarmed, it renders you contemptible; which is one of those disgraceful things which a prince must guard against"
About this Quote
Machiavelli doesn’t bother with moral panic about violence; he goes straight for the political emotion that actually moves regimes: contempt. “Disarmed” here is less about weapons than about the visible capacity to coerce, defend, and punish. A prince who cannot credibly do those things becomes, in Machiavelli’s cold optics, a figure others feel licensed to ignore. The real “evil” isn’t vulnerability in the abstract. It’s the social permission structure that vulnerability creates.
The line’s bite comes from its inversion of what a pious ruler might say. In the conventional Christian-humanist register of Machiavelli’s day, humility and restraint read as virtues. Machiavelli flips the script: restraint can curdle into disgrace if it signals weakness. “Contemptible” is not an insult but a strategic diagnosis. Once contempt enters the bloodstream of a court or a populace, loyalty becomes conditional, conspiracies become thinkable, and allies become transactional. Fear and love may be debated; contempt is fatal because it erodes the basic belief that power is real.
Context matters: Renaissance Italy was a patchwork of city-states hiring mercenaries, swapping allegiances, and being carved up by France and Spain. Machiavelli watched Florence pay for “security” and get betrayal instead. So “being disarmed” also reads as outsourcing force, letting others hold the sword while you hold the title.
The subtext is brutally modern: legitimacy isn’t just law or virtue; it’s performance backed by capability. A prince must guard against disgrace the way a brand guards against irrelevance: once people stop taking you seriously, your authority becomes an empty costume.
The line’s bite comes from its inversion of what a pious ruler might say. In the conventional Christian-humanist register of Machiavelli’s day, humility and restraint read as virtues. Machiavelli flips the script: restraint can curdle into disgrace if it signals weakness. “Contemptible” is not an insult but a strategic diagnosis. Once contempt enters the bloodstream of a court or a populace, loyalty becomes conditional, conspiracies become thinkable, and allies become transactional. Fear and love may be debated; contempt is fatal because it erodes the basic belief that power is real.
Context matters: Renaissance Italy was a patchwork of city-states hiring mercenaries, swapping allegiances, and being carved up by France and Spain. Machiavelli watched Florence pay for “security” and get betrayal instead. So “being disarmed” also reads as outsourcing force, letting others hold the sword while you hold the title.
The subtext is brutally modern: legitimacy isn’t just law or virtue; it’s performance backed by capability. A prince must guard against disgrace the way a brand guards against irrelevance: once people stop taking you seriously, your authority becomes an empty costume.
Quote Details
| Topic | Leadership |
|---|
More Quotes by Niccolo
Add to List








