"He had no failings which were not owing to a noble cause; to an ardent, generous, perhaps an immoderate passion for fame; a passion which is the instinct of all great souls"
About this Quote
Burke is pulling off a political magic trick: defending a man’s flaws by upgrading them into virtues with bad optics. “He had no failings which were not owing to a noble cause” doesn’t deny error; it launders it. The sentence invites you to stop reading like an accountant and start reading like a moral biographer, where motive matters more than outcome.
The key move is the calibrated praise of “fame.” In Burke’s hands, ambition isn’t petty vanity; it’s the fuel of public greatness. He concedes just enough to sound credible - “perhaps an immoderate passion” - then converts excess into evidence of scale. That little “perhaps” is doing diplomatic work: it nods to critics while keeping the subject inside the circle of the admirable. “Ardent” and “generous” frame fame not as self-advertising but as a hunger to be worthy of admiration, to be seen doing something that counts.
Subtextually, Burke is also arguing about how leaders should be judged. A statesman’s moral economy isn’t private piety; it’s the visible record of action, reputation, legacy. Fame becomes a proxy for responsibility: if history is watching, you behave as if your choices will have consequences beyond the room. Calling it “the instinct of all great souls” turns a suspect motive into a near-biological impulse, implying that to lack it is to lack grandeur itself.
Context matters because Burke lived amid revolutions and reputational warfare. In an age when “ambition” could sound like treason to stability, he makes the desire for glory safe by baptizing it as public-spirited. The defense is less about one man than about rescuing elite aspiration from the charge of mere self-interest.
The key move is the calibrated praise of “fame.” In Burke’s hands, ambition isn’t petty vanity; it’s the fuel of public greatness. He concedes just enough to sound credible - “perhaps an immoderate passion” - then converts excess into evidence of scale. That little “perhaps” is doing diplomatic work: it nods to critics while keeping the subject inside the circle of the admirable. “Ardent” and “generous” frame fame not as self-advertising but as a hunger to be worthy of admiration, to be seen doing something that counts.
Subtextually, Burke is also arguing about how leaders should be judged. A statesman’s moral economy isn’t private piety; it’s the visible record of action, reputation, legacy. Fame becomes a proxy for responsibility: if history is watching, you behave as if your choices will have consequences beyond the room. Calling it “the instinct of all great souls” turns a suspect motive into a near-biological impulse, implying that to lack it is to lack grandeur itself.
Context matters because Burke lived amid revolutions and reputational warfare. In an age when “ambition” could sound like treason to stability, he makes the desire for glory safe by baptizing it as public-spirited. The defense is less about one man than about rescuing elite aspiration from the charge of mere self-interest.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Edmund
Add to List










