"If in doubt, move decisions up to the President"
About this Quote
Rumsfeld distilled a hard lesson of presidential government: when uncertainty clouds stakes and authority, elevate the choice to the one person elected to reconcile competing imperatives. In the White House and the Pentagon he saw how ambiguity feeds paralysis, turf fights, and blame-shifting. Pushing a hard call to the President imposes unity of command, confers democratic legitimacy, and sets a clear vector for the bureaucracy. Only the President can weigh political risk against military necessity, legal constraints against diplomatic fallout, and then accept the consequences before the country.
The line comes from Rumsfelds Rules, the terse management maxims he honed as White House chief of staff under Ford and later as defense secretary under George W. Bush. It reflects the reality of the American system: interagency processes can refine options, but only the President can trade among values when they conflict. It is also a prophylactic against the quiet vetoes of middle management, where delay and endless staffing can decide by not deciding.
It is not a license to dump problems upward. Rumsfeld also argued that decisions should be made at the lowest competent level and that leaders must own their lanes. The art lies in judgment: elevate when the issue touches presidential equities, crosses departmental boundaries, risks irreversibility, or exposes the nation to strategic hazard. When escalation is warranted, staff work must be crisp and candid: present real alternatives, consequences, timelines, and dissenting views, rather than a single pre-cooked answer.
The early war on terror shows both the strength and the peril of centralization. Elevating choices produced speed and coherence across agencies; yet too much concentration can crowd out field learning. The rule therefore demands discipline both ways. Use it to secure accountability and coherence when doubt prevails, and pair it with the courage to decide at your level when you should.
The line comes from Rumsfelds Rules, the terse management maxims he honed as White House chief of staff under Ford and later as defense secretary under George W. Bush. It reflects the reality of the American system: interagency processes can refine options, but only the President can trade among values when they conflict. It is also a prophylactic against the quiet vetoes of middle management, where delay and endless staffing can decide by not deciding.
It is not a license to dump problems upward. Rumsfeld also argued that decisions should be made at the lowest competent level and that leaders must own their lanes. The art lies in judgment: elevate when the issue touches presidential equities, crosses departmental boundaries, risks irreversibility, or exposes the nation to strategic hazard. When escalation is warranted, staff work must be crisp and candid: present real alternatives, consequences, timelines, and dissenting views, rather than a single pre-cooked answer.
The early war on terror shows both the strength and the peril of centralization. Elevating choices produced speed and coherence across agencies; yet too much concentration can crowd out field learning. The rule therefore demands discipline both ways. Use it to secure accountability and coherence when doubt prevails, and pair it with the courage to decide at your level when you should.
Quote Details
| Topic | Decision-Making |
|---|
More Quotes by Donald
Add to List
