Famous quote by Felix Frankfurter

"It is anomalous to hold that in order to convict a man the police cannot extract by force what is in his mind, but can extract what is in his stomach"

About this Quote

Felix Frankfurter's quote discuss significant principles in law and principles, drawing attention to the borders of cops power and private rights. At its core, the declaration critiques the disparity in legal approaches to individual autonomy and privacy, particularly in the context of criminal justice and evidence event.

Frankfurter contrasts 2 situations: one where the police are forbidden from utilizing coercion to elicit thoughts or confessions from a person's mind, and the other where the legal system may permit physical force or coercion to extract physical proof, such as the contents of an individual's stomach. This juxtaposition highlights a viewed inconsistency or anomaly in the defense extended to psychological versus physical integrity.

The concept of protecting an individual's mind from coercion is rooted in the right against self-incrimination, an essential concept in numerous legal systems, especially in the United States under the Fifth Amendment. This best ensures individuals are not compelled to affirm versus themselves, protecting the stability of individual thought and the flexibility from pushed confessions.

On the other hand, the quote concerns whether comparable securities ought to reach the physical domain, stressing the importance of thinking about the methods utilized to get evidence. Frankfurter's use of the word "anomalous" suggests that it is illogical or perhaps unjust to have different standards for the body and mind, indicating that both ought to be equally protected from coercive extraction approaches.

The quote invites much deeper reflection on the ethical lines drawn in between mental and physical evidence event. It challenges the legal system to think about consistency in maintaining human dignity and autonomy across all elements of proof collection. Frankfurter's insight motivates a broader discussion on how laws must develop to protect people adequately, promoting for a balance in between efficient police and fundamental human rights.

More details

TagsPolice

About the Author

USA Flag This quote is from Felix Frankfurter between November 15, 1882 and February 22, 1965. He/she was a famous Judge from USA. The author also have 24 other quotes.
See more from Felix Frankfurter

Similar Quotes

Seneca the Younger, Statesman
Small: Seneca the Younger
Shortlist

No items yet. Click "Add" on a Quote.