"It's always the generals with the bloodiest records who are the first to shout what a hell it is. And it's always the war widows who lead the Memorial Day parades"
About this Quote
Paddy Chayefsky yokes two ironies into one sharp observation about how societies talk about war. The men who order and manage the slaughter are often the first to declare that war is hell, a posture that sounds honest yet doubles as self-exoneration. William Tecumseh Sherman famously said "War is hell", and it is no accident that the words resound through the mouths of those with the longest casualty lists. Such declarations advertise moral clarity without requiring a change in behavior; they confer the aura of hard-earned wisdom while leaving the machinery intact.
The second image shows grief converted into pageantry. War widows lead Memorial Day parades, their loss placed at the front of civic ritual. The spectacle sanctifies the dead, but it also serves a quieter function: it turns private pain into public legitimacy, wrapping mourning in patriotic symbolism that can make questioning the war feel like dishonoring the bereaved. By positioning victims as ceremonial standard-bearers, the culture renders remembrance safe, solemn, and ultimately useful to the same institutions that produced the loss.
Chayefsky, whose work from Marty to Network and The Americanization of Emily skewers euphemism and institutional hypocrisy, attacks the sentimentalization of sacrifice. He suggests that condemnation and celebration coexist not as contradiction but as choreography. The generals lament to signal conscience; the widows march to confer grace. Together they form a narrative that transforms violence into myth and history into civic religion, one that consoles, flatters, and permits repetition.
Set against mid-century American pieties and anxieties, the line resists the romance of heroism and the anesthetic of ceremony. It asks who controls memory, whose voices are instrumentalized, and how rhetoric about horror can absolve those who wield it. The sting endures because the structure endures: the killers lament, the mourners lead, and the system keeps moving.
The second image shows grief converted into pageantry. War widows lead Memorial Day parades, their loss placed at the front of civic ritual. The spectacle sanctifies the dead, but it also serves a quieter function: it turns private pain into public legitimacy, wrapping mourning in patriotic symbolism that can make questioning the war feel like dishonoring the bereaved. By positioning victims as ceremonial standard-bearers, the culture renders remembrance safe, solemn, and ultimately useful to the same institutions that produced the loss.
Chayefsky, whose work from Marty to Network and The Americanization of Emily skewers euphemism and institutional hypocrisy, attacks the sentimentalization of sacrifice. He suggests that condemnation and celebration coexist not as contradiction but as choreography. The generals lament to signal conscience; the widows march to confer grace. Together they form a narrative that transforms violence into myth and history into civic religion, one that consoles, flatters, and permits repetition.
Set against mid-century American pieties and anxieties, the line resists the romance of heroism and the anesthetic of ceremony. It asks who controls memory, whose voices are instrumentalized, and how rhetoric about horror can absolve those who wield it. The sting endures because the structure endures: the killers lament, the mourners lead, and the system keeps moving.
Quote Details
| Topic | War |
|---|
More Quotes by Paddy
Add to List
