"Man, as a physical being, is like other bodies governed by invariable laws"
About this Quote
Man belongs to nature, and his body obeys the same necessities as falling stones or orbiting planets. Charles de Secondat, better known as Montesquieu, uses that sober claim to clear a path for a scientific study of society. If the physical side of human life is subject to invariable laws, then politics and law must reckon with regularities in climate, geography, demography, and commerce. He is not reducing people to matter; he is insisting that human arrangements do not float free of the world that sustains them.
The line comes from the opening of The Spirit of the Laws, where he defines laws as the necessary relations arising from the nature of things. He sketches a duality: as physical beings, humans are governed by necessity; as intelligent and passionate beings, they can deviate, err, and choose. That tension underwrites his project. Legislators must design institutions that acknowledge natural constraints while channeling human freedom. Separation of powers, checks and balances, and the cultivation of civic virtue are ways to harness volatile passions within stable structures.
He also pioneers a comparative method. By examining how climate, soil, and economy shape mores and institutions, he argues that laws cannot be one-size-fits-all. Cold and hot climates, vast or compact territories, agrarian or commercial societies each set different parameters. The phrase invariable laws does not license fatalism. It counsels respect for limits and a search for the underlying causes that make some forms workable and others destructive. Good laws accord with the grain of circumstances; bad laws ignore it and break.
The deeper point is Enlightenment confidence that human affairs can be understood without recourse to miracle or arbitrary will. By placing man within nature, Montesquieu elevates politics into a disciplined inquiry. The dignity of human choice remains, but it operates within a framework of necessity that wise law recognizes and prudently employs.
The line comes from the opening of The Spirit of the Laws, where he defines laws as the necessary relations arising from the nature of things. He sketches a duality: as physical beings, humans are governed by necessity; as intelligent and passionate beings, they can deviate, err, and choose. That tension underwrites his project. Legislators must design institutions that acknowledge natural constraints while channeling human freedom. Separation of powers, checks and balances, and the cultivation of civic virtue are ways to harness volatile passions within stable structures.
He also pioneers a comparative method. By examining how climate, soil, and economy shape mores and institutions, he argues that laws cannot be one-size-fits-all. Cold and hot climates, vast or compact territories, agrarian or commercial societies each set different parameters. The phrase invariable laws does not license fatalism. It counsels respect for limits and a search for the underlying causes that make some forms workable and others destructive. Good laws accord with the grain of circumstances; bad laws ignore it and break.
The deeper point is Enlightenment confidence that human affairs can be understood without recourse to miracle or arbitrary will. By placing man within nature, Montesquieu elevates politics into a disciplined inquiry. The dignity of human choice remains, but it operates within a framework of necessity that wise law recognizes and prudently employs.
Quote Details
| Topic | Free Will & Fate |
|---|
More Quotes by Charles
Add to List
