"One is often guilty by being too just"
About this Quote
Justice sounds like armor, but Corneille is warning it can function like a target. "One is often guilty by being too just" carries the theatrical sting of a dramatist who understood how virtue plays under pressure: not as a halo, but as a provocation. In courts of power, the person who insists on fairness doesn’t simply enforce rules; they expose everyone else’s compromises. That exposure creates enemies, and enemies manufacture guilt.
The subtext is less about abstract morality than about social physics. Being "too just" is a refusal to participate in the lubricants that keep hierarchies running: favoritism, selective blindness, pardon-by-connection. Excess justice becomes a kind of accusation. It implies others are not just enough, and that’s intolerable in a culture where reputation is currency. So the just person gets recast as rigid, sanctimonious, even dangerous. Corneille’s phrase catches the paradox: the community treats uncompromising integrity as a breach of solidarity.
Context matters. Corneille wrote in 17th-century France, where honor, royal authority, and public performance shaped the moral imagination. His tragedies stage characters trapped between duty and affection, law and loyalty, private conscience and public expectation. In that world, righteousness isn’t rewarded; it’s negotiated. The line reads like a cynical aside from someone who has watched virtue become evidence: the more consistently you apply principle, the easier it is for others to frame you as heartless, disloyal, or destabilizing.
Corneille isn’t telling us to abandon justice. He’s naming its cost: in flawed systems, fairness can be treated as treason.
The subtext is less about abstract morality than about social physics. Being "too just" is a refusal to participate in the lubricants that keep hierarchies running: favoritism, selective blindness, pardon-by-connection. Excess justice becomes a kind of accusation. It implies others are not just enough, and that’s intolerable in a culture where reputation is currency. So the just person gets recast as rigid, sanctimonious, even dangerous. Corneille’s phrase catches the paradox: the community treats uncompromising integrity as a breach of solidarity.
Context matters. Corneille wrote in 17th-century France, where honor, royal authority, and public performance shaped the moral imagination. His tragedies stage characters trapped between duty and affection, law and loyalty, private conscience and public expectation. In that world, righteousness isn’t rewarded; it’s negotiated. The line reads like a cynical aside from someone who has watched virtue become evidence: the more consistently you apply principle, the easier it is for others to frame you as heartless, disloyal, or destabilizing.
Corneille isn’t telling us to abandon justice. He’s naming its cost: in flawed systems, fairness can be treated as treason.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Pierre
Add to List




