"Sir, my concern is not whether God is on our side; my greatest concern is to be on God's side, for God is always right"
About this Quote
Lincoln is doing something politically risky and rhetorically brilliant here: he refuses to draft God into the war as a mascot. In the middle of the Civil War, both North and South claimed providence as a partisan endorsement, turning the Almighty into the ultimate campaign surrogate. Lincoln flips the script. The line sounds pious, but its real edge is moral discipline. It denies the comforting fantasy that victory equals virtue and insists that righteousness is not automatically conferred by belonging to the “right” army.
The intent is twofold. First, it’s a rebuke to religious triumphalism. “Is God on our side?” is the question of propaganda, the question that lets you outsource your conscience to outcome. Lincoln replaces it with an inward-facing test: are we aligned with a standard that transcends our interests? Second, it’s an argument for humility under unimaginable stakes. By asserting “God is always right,” Lincoln isn’t claiming certainty about God’s plans; he’s admitting the possibility of national error, even in a cause he believed just.
The subtext is almost prosecutorial: if God is the measure, then “our side” can’t be the measure. That opens space for moral reckoning - about slavery, about bloodshed, about the temptation to sanctify power. It also makes strategic sense. A president trying to hold together a fragile coalition can’t afford a theology that blesses every decision in advance. Lincoln’s phrasing creates a high ground that is ethical, not tribal: a standard that can judge him, not just validate him.
The intent is twofold. First, it’s a rebuke to religious triumphalism. “Is God on our side?” is the question of propaganda, the question that lets you outsource your conscience to outcome. Lincoln replaces it with an inward-facing test: are we aligned with a standard that transcends our interests? Second, it’s an argument for humility under unimaginable stakes. By asserting “God is always right,” Lincoln isn’t claiming certainty about God’s plans; he’s admitting the possibility of national error, even in a cause he believed just.
The subtext is almost prosecutorial: if God is the measure, then “our side” can’t be the measure. That opens space for moral reckoning - about slavery, about bloodshed, about the temptation to sanctify power. It also makes strategic sense. A president trying to hold together a fragile coalition can’t afford a theology that blesses every decision in advance. Lincoln’s phrasing creates a high ground that is ethical, not tribal: a standard that can judge him, not just validate him.
Quote Details
| Topic | God |
|---|---|
| Source | Later attribution: God Is Bigger !!! (Danny Ray Christian, 2021) modern compilationISBN: 9781664178021 · ID: U88yEAAAQBAJ
Evidence: ... Sir , my concern is not whether God is on our side ; my greatest concern is to be on God's side , for God is always right . Abraham Lincoln Abraham Lincoln ( '11 ŋkən ; February 12 , 1809 April 15 , 1865 ) was an American statesman and ... Other candidates (1) Abraham Lincoln (Abraham Lincoln) compilation36.2% hoose to serve you go with them but as you have made up your organization upon principle stand by it for as surely as... |
More Quotes by Abraham
Add to List





